One thing I should like to learn
from one of such eminent sanctity and fastidiousness, (whose holiness
is such that in the presence of your very handkerchiefs and aprons the
devils cry out); whom do you take for your model in your writings? Has
any one of the catholic writers, in a controversy of opinions, imputed
moral offences to the man with whom he is arguing? Have your masters
taught you to do this? Is this the system in which you have been
trained, that, when you cannot answer a man, you should take off his
head? that when you cannot silence a man’s tongue, you should cut
it out? You have nothing much to boast of, for you are doing only what
the scorpions and cantharides do. This is what Fulvia Anthony’s wife who had Cicero’s head brought to her,
and bored through the tongue with a golden bodkin. did to Cicero and Herodias to John.
They could not bear to hear the truth, and therefore they pierced the tongue
that spoke truth with the pin that parted their hair. The duty of dogs
is to bark in their masters’ service; why may I not bark in the
service of Christ? Many have written against Marcion or Valentinus,
Arius or Eunomius. By which of them was any accusation brought of
immoral conduct? Did they not in each case bring their whole effort to
bear upon the refutation of the heresy? It is the machination of the
heretics, that is of your masters, when convicted of betrayal of the
faith, to betake themselves to evil speaking. So Eustathius Eustathius was deposed at the instigation of Eusebius the Arian
bishop of Nicomedia, who brought charges both of Sabellianism and of
immorality against him. Socrates, Eccl. Hist. i. 24. the Bishop of Antioch was made into a
father unawares. So Athanasius Bishop of Alexandria cut off a third
hand of Arsenius; for, when he appeared At
the Synod at Tyre in 335. See Socrates Eccl. Hist. i. 29.
alive after having been supposed to be dead, he was found to have two.
Such things also now are falsely charged against the Bishop of the same
church, and the true faith is assailed by gold, which constitutes the
power of yourself and your friends. But I need not speak of controversy
with heretics, who, though they are really without, yet call themselves
Christians. How many of our writers have contended with those most
impious men, Celsus and Porphyry! but which of them has left the cause
he was engaged in to busy himself with the imputation of crime to his
adversary, such as ought to be set down not in church-writings but in
the calendar of the judge? For what advantage have you gained if you
establish a man’s criminality but fail in your argument? It is
quite unnecessary that in bringing an accusation you should risk your
own head. If your object is revenge, you can hire an executioner, and
satisfy your desire. You pretend to dread a scandal, and yet you are
ready to kill a man who was once your brother, whom you now accuse, and
whom you always treat as an enemy. Yet I wonder how a man like you, who
knows what he is about, should be so blinded by madness as to wish to
confer a benefit upon me by drawing forth my soul out of prison, This expression was used by the Origenists of death. This life was
a prison house into which souls had fallen; Jerome imputes this opinion
to Rufinus, and Rufinus to him. See Ruf, Apol. i. 26. and should not suffer it to remain with
you in the darkness of this world.