(1.) On leaving the church of Theonas, Athanasius
appears to have made his escape from the city. If for once we may
hazard a conjecture, the numerous cells of the Nitrian desert offered a
not too distant but fairly inpenetrable refuge. He must at any rate
have selected a place where he could gain time to reflect on the
situation, and above all ensure that he should be kept well informed of
events from time to time. For in Athanasius we never see the
panic-stricken outlaw; he is always the general meditating his next
movement and full of the prospects of his cause. He made up his mind to
appeal to Constantius in person. He could not believe that an Emperor
would go back upon his solemn pledges, especially such a voluntary
assurance as he had received after the death of Constans. Accordingly
he drew up a carefully elaborated defence (Ap. Const.
1–26) dealing with the four principal charges against him, and
set off through the Libyan The
envoys of Magnentius had come from Italy through Libya in
350–351. The ‘desert’ (Apol. Const. 27, 32)
must be the region between Alxa. and Cyrenaica, not
Palestine as Tillem. viii. 186, infers from Ep. Æg.
5. There is no evidence that Ath. left his province during this exile,
and Palestine was a most dangerous territory to venture into. The
cautious vagueness of his language, Ep. Æg. 5, while it
baffles even our curiosity, yet favours the hypothesis that the events
referred to belong to the Egyptian persecution. desert with the
intention of crossing to Italy and finding Constantius at Milan. But
while he was on his way, he encountered rumours confirming the reports
of the wholesale banishment not only of the recalcitrants of Milan, but
of Liberius of Rome and the great Hosius of Spain. Next came the news
of the severe measures against Egyptian bishops, and of the banishment
of sixteen of their number, coupled with the violence practised by the
troops at Alexandria on Easter Day (p. 248 sq.); however, his
journey was continued, until he received copies of letters from the
Emperor, one denouncing him to the Alexandrians and recommending a new
bishop, one George, as their future guide, the other summoning the
princes of Auxumis to send Frumentius (supr. p. xlviii.) to
Egypt in order that he might unlearn what he had been taught by
‘the most wicked Athanasius’ and receive instruction from
the ‘venerable George.’ These letters, which shew how
completely the pursuers were off the scent (p. 249), convinced
Athanasius that a personal interview was out of the question. He
returned ‘into the desert,’ and at leisure completed his
apology (pp. 249–253), with the view partly of possible future
delivery, partly no doubt of literary circulation. Before turning back,
however, he appears to have drawn up his letter to the bishops of Egypt
and Libya, warning them against the formula (see p. 222) which was
being tendered for their subscription, and encouraging them to endure
persecution, which had already begun at least in Libya (Ep.
Æg.); the designation of George (§7) was already known,
but he had not arrived, nor had Secundus (19) reappeared in Egypt, at
any rate not in Libya (he was there in Lent, 357, p. 294). The letter
to the bishops, then, must have been written about Easter, 356; not
long after, because it contains no
details of the persecution in Egypt; not before, for the persecution
had already begun, and Athanasius was already in Cyrenaica, whence he
turned back not earlier than April (to allow time for Constantius (1)
to hear that Athanasius was thought to have fled to Ethiopia, (2) to
write to Egypt, (3) for copies of the letter to overtake Athanasius on
his way to Italy. Constantius was at Milan Jan.–April).