belief: but to those who are dense and indefinite this term serves as a starting-point for de-
flection from sound doctrine. For not understanding the true force of the term, that “ungen-
erate” signifies nothing more than “not having come into being,” and that “not coming into
being” is a common property of all that transcends created nature, they drop their faith in
the Father, and substitute for “Father” the phrase “ungenerate:” and since, as has been said,
the Personal existence of the Only-begotten is not connoted in this name, they determine
the existence of the Son to have commenced from some definite beginning in time, affirming
(what Eunomius here adds to his previous statements) that He is called Son not without
generation preceding His existence.
What is this vain juggling with words? Is he aware that it is God of Whom he speaks,
Who was in the beginning and is in the Father, nor was there any time when He was not?
He knows not what he says nor whereof he affirms359, but he endeavours, as though he were
constructing the pedigree of a mere man, to apply to the Lord of all creation the language
which properly belongs to our nature here below. For, to take an example, Ishmael was not
before the generation that brought him into being, and before his birth there was of course
an interval of time. But with Him Who is “the brightness of glory360,” “before” and “after”
have no place: for before the brightness, of course neither was there any glory, for concur-
rently with the existence of the glory there assuredly beams forth its brightness; and it is
impossible in the nature of things that one should be severed from the other, nor is it possible
to see the glory by itself before its brightness. For he who says thus will make out the glory
in itself to be darkling and dim, if the brightness from it does not shine out at the same time.
But this is the unfair method of the heresy, to endeavour, by the notions and terms employed
concerning the Only-begotten God, to displace Him from His oneness with the Father. It
is to this end they say, “Before the generation that brought Him into being He was not Son:”
but the “sons of rams361,” of whom the prophet speaks,—are not they too called sons after
coming into being? That quality, then, which reason notices in the “sons of rams,” that they
are not “sons of rams” before the generation which brings them into being,—this our reverend
divine now ascribes to the Maker of the worlds and of all creation, Who has the Eternal
Father in Himself, and is contemplated in the eternity of the Father, as He Himself says, “I
am in the Father, and the Father in Me362.” Those, however, who are not able to detect the
sophistry that lurks in his statement, and are not trained to any sort of logical perception,
follow these inconsequent statements and receive what comes next as a logical consequence
of what preceded. For he says, “coming into being before all creation,” and as though this
359 Cf. 1 Tim. i. 7
360 Cf. Heb. i. 3
361 Ps. cxiv. 4, in Septuagint.
362 S. John xiv. 10
222
Gregory again discusses the generation of the Only-Begotten, and other different…