24. But, my opponent says, these are not the rites of our state. Who, pray, says this, or
who repeats it? Is he Roman, Gaul, Spaniard, African, German, or Sicilian? And what does
it avail your cause if these stories are not yours, while those who compose them are on your
side? Or of what importance is it whether you approve of them or not, since what you
yourselves say4426 are found to be either just as foul, or of even greater baseness? For do
you wish that we should consider the mysteries and those ceremonies which are named by
499
the Greeks Thesmophoria,4427 in which those holy vigils and solemn watchings were con-
secrated to the goddess by the Athenians? Do you wish us, I say, to see what beginnings they
have, what causes, that we may prove that Athens itself also, distinguished in the arts and
pursuits of civilization, says things as insulting to the gods as others, and that stories are
there publicly related under the mask of religion just as disgraceful as are thrown in our way
by the rest of you? Once, they say, when Proserpine, not yet a woman and still a maiden,
was gathering purple flowers in the meadows of Sicily, and when her eagerness to gather
them was leading her hither and thither in all directions, the king of the shades, springing
forth through an opening of unknown depth, seizes and bears away with him the maiden,
and conceals himself again in the bowels4428 of the earth. Now when Ceres did not know
what had happened, and had no idea where in the world her daughter was, she set herself
to seek the lost one all over the4429 world. She snatches up two torches lit at the fires of
4426 Lit., “what are your proper things.”
4427 Every one since Salmasius (ad solinum, p. 750) has supposed Arnobius to have here fallen into a gross
error, by confounding the Eleusinian mysteries with the Thesmophoria; an error the less accountable, because
they are carefully distinguished by Clemens Alexandrinus, whom Arnobius evidently had before him, as usual.
There seems to be no sufficient reason, however, for charging Arnobius with such a blunder, although in the
end of ch. 26 he refers to the story just related as showing the base character of the Eleusinia (Eleusiniorum
vestrorum notas); as he here speaks of mysteria(i.e., Eleusinia, cf. Nepos, Alc., 3, 16) et illa divina quæ Thesmo-
phoria nominantur a Græcis. It should be remembered also that there was much in common between these
mysteries: the story of Ceres’ wanderings was the subject of both; in both there was a season of fasting to recall
her sadness; both had indecent allusions to the way in which that sadness was dispelled; and both celebrated
with some freedom the recovery of cheerfulness by the goddess, the great distinguishing feature of the Thesmo-
phoria being that only women could take part in its rites. Now, as it is to the points in which the two sets of
mysteries were at one that allusion is made in the passage which follows, it was only natural that Arnobius should
not be very careful to distinguish the one from the other, seeing that he was concerned not with their differences,
but with their coincidence. It seems difficult, therefore, to maintain that Arnobius has here convicted himself
of so utter ignorance and so gross carelessness as his critics have imagined. [Vol. ii. p. 176.]
4428 Lit., “caverns.”
4429 Lit., “in the whole.”
Chapter XXIV.
1198
Chapter XXIV.