Book XXVI.
Faustus insists that Jesus might have died though not born, by the exercise of divine
power, yet he rejects birth and death alike. Augustin maintains that there are some things
that even God cannot do, one of which is to die. He refutes the docetism of the Manichæans.
1. Faustus said: You ask, If Jesus was not born, how did He die? Well this is a probab-
ility, such as one makes use of in want of proofs. We will, however, answer the question by
examples taken from what you generally believe. If they are true, they will prove our case;
321
if they are false, they will help you no more than they will us. You say then, How could Jesus
die, if He were not man? In return, I ask you, How did Elias not die, though he was a man?
Could a mortal encroach upon the limits of immortality, and could not Christ add to His
immortality whatever experience of death was required? If Elias, contrary to nature, lives
for ever, why not allow that Jesus, with no greater contrariety to nature, could remain in
death for three days? Besides that, it is not only Elias, but Moses and Enoch you believe to
be immortal, and to have been taken up with their bodies to heaven. Accordingly, if it is a
good argument that Jesus was a man because He died, it is an equally good argument that
Elias was not a man because he did not die. But as it is false that Elias was not a man, not-
withstanding his supposed immortality, so it is false that Jesus was a man, though He is
considered to have died. The truth is, if you will believe it, that the Hebrews were in a mistake
regarding both the death of Jesus and the immortality of Elias. For it is equally untrue that
Jesus died and that Elias did not die. But you believe whatever you please; and for the rest,
you appeal to nature. And, allowing this appeal, nature is against both the death of the im-
mortal and the immortality of the mortal. And if we refer to the power of effecting their
purpose as possessed by God and by man, it seems more possible for Jesus to die than for
Elias not to die; for the power of Jesus is greater than that of Elias. But if you exalt the
weaker to heaven, though nature is against it, and, forgetting his condition as a mortal, endow
him with eternal felicity, why should I not admit that Jesus could die if He pleased, even
though I were to grant His death to have been real, and not a mere semblance? For, as from
the outset of His taking the likeness of man He underwent in appearance all the experiences
of humanity, it was quite consistent that He should complete the system by appearing to
die.
2. Moreover, it is to be remembered that this reference to what nature grants as possible,
should be made in connection with all the history of Jesus, and not only with His death.
According to nature, it is impossible that a man blind from his birth should see the light;
and yet Jesus appears to have performed a miracle of this kind, so that the Jews themselves
exclaimed that from the beginning of the world it was not seen that one opened the eyes of
a man born blind.999 So also healing a withered hand, giving the power of utterance and
999 John ix.
Faustus insists that Jesus might have died though not born, by the exercise of divine power, yet he rejects birth and death alike. Augustin maintains that there are some things that even God cannot do, one of which is to die. He refutes the docetism of the Manichæans.
547
Faustus insists that Jesus might have died though not born, by the exercise…