Of the mass of instances where the bishops were
not Arian but simply conservative, the Church of Jerusalem is the type.
We have the instructions given to the Catechumens of this city between
348 and 350 by Cyril, who in the latter year
(Hort, p. 92) became bishop, and whose career is typical of the
rise and development of so-called semi-Arianism. Cyril, like the
conservatives generally, is strongly under the influence of Origen (see
Caspari iv. 146–162, and of. the Catechesis in Heurtley
de Fid. et Symb. 62 with the Regula Fidei in Orig. de
Princ. i.). The instructions insist strongly on the necessity of
scriptural language, and while contradicting the doctrines of
Arius (without mentioning his name; cf. Athanasius on Marcellus and
Photinus in pp. 433–447) Cyril tacitly protests against the ὁμοούσιον as of
human contrivance (Cat. v. 12), and uses in preference the words
‘like to the Father according to the Scriptures’ or
‘in all things.’ This language is that of Athanasius also,
especially in his earlier works (pp. 84 sqq.), but in the latter
phase of the controversy, especially in the Dated Creed of 359, which
presents striking resemblances to Cyril’s Catecheses, it became
the watchword of the party of reaction. The Church of Jerusalem then
was orthodox substantially, but rejected the Nicene formula, and this
was the case in the East generally, except where the bishops were
positively Arian. All were aggrieved at the way in which the Eastern
councils had been treated by the West, and smarted under a sense of
defeat (cf. Bright, Introd. to Hist. Tr., p. xviii.).