TO PAMMACHIUS AGAINST JOHN OF JERUSALEM.
429
your letter thus begin : " Let him be ac-
cursed who has dared to write such things." Pure faith is impatient of delay. As soon as
the scorpion appears, he must be crushed un- der foot. David, who was proved to be a
man after God's own heart, says : ' " Do not I hate those that hate thee, O Lord, and did
not I pine away over thine enemies ? I hated
them with a perfect hatred." Had I heard my father, or mother, or brother say such
things against my Master Christ, I would
have broken their blasphemous jaws like
those of a mad dog, and my hand should have
been amongst the first lifted up against them.
They who said to father and mother,2 " We
know you not," these men fulfilled the will of the Lord. ' He that loveth father or mother more than Christ, is not worthy of Him.
9. It is alleged that yourmaster, whom you
call a Catholic, and whom you resolutely de-
fend, said, " the Son sees not the Father, and
the Holy Spirit sees not the Son." And you tell me that the Father is invisible, the Son
invisible, the Holy Ghost invisible, as though
the angels, both cherubim and seraphim, were
not also, in accordance with their nature,
invisible to our eyes. David was certainly
in doubt even as regards the appearance of
the heavens : * " I shall see," he says, " the
heavens, the works of Thy fingers." I shall see, not I see. I shall see when with unveiled
face I shall behold the glory of the Lord : but
6 now we see in part, and we know in part. The question is whether the Son sees the
Father, and you say " The Father is invisible." It is disputed whether the Holy Spirit sees the
Son, and you answer" The Son is invisible." The point at issue is, whether the Trinity have
mutually the vision of one another ; human
ears cannot endure such blasphemy, and you
say the Trinity is invisible. You wander in
the realms of praise in all other directions ;
you spend your eloquence on things which no
one wants to hear about. You put your
nearer off the scent, to avoid telling us what
we ask for. But granted that all this is super- fluous. We make you a present of the fact
that you are not an Arian ; nay, even more,
that you never have been. We allow that in
the explanation of the first section no suspi-
cion rests upon you, and that all that you said
was frank and free from error. We speak to
you with equal frankness. Did our father in
God, Epiphanius, accuse you of being an
Arian ? Did he fasten upon you the heresy of
* Kunomius, the Godless, or that of 7Aerius ?
1 Ps. cxxxix. ai, 22. * Deut. xxxiii. 9. 3 Matt. x. 37.
* Ps. viii. 3. • i Cor. xiii. 9.
• Eunomius held that the Son " resembles the Father in noth-
ing but his working." and similar doctrines.
7 Of Sebaste, in the lesser Armenia. Epiphanius described him as an Arinn. He asserted that Bishops and Presbyters were
equal.
The point of the whole letter is that jou fol- low the erroneous doctrines of Origen, and
are associated with others in this heresy.
Why, when a question is put to you on one
point, do you give an answer about another ;
and, as if you were speaking to fools, hide the
charges contained in the letters, and tell us
what you said in the church in the presence
of Epiphanius ? A confession of faith is de- manded of you, and you inflict upon us your
very eloquent dissertations. I beseech my
readers to remember the judgment seat of
the Lord, and as you know that you must be
judged for the judgment you give, favour
neither me nor my opponent, and consider
not the persons of the arguers, but the case
itself. Let us then continue what we began.
10. You write in your letter that, before Pau-
linianus was made a presbyter, the pope
Epiphanius never took you to task in con-
nection with Origen's errors. To begin with, this is doubtful, and I have to consider which
of the two men I should believe. He says
that he did object, you deny it ; he brings
forward witnesses, you will not listen to them
when they are produced ; he even relates
that ' another besides yourself was arraigned by him : you refuse to admit this in the case
of either ; he sends a letter to you by one of
his clergy, and demands an answer : you are
silent, dare not open your lips, and, chal-
lenged in Palestine, speak at Alexandria.
Which of you is to be believed is not for me
to say. I suppose that you yourself would
not, in the face of so distinguished a man, ven-
ture to claim truth for yourself, and impute
falsehood to him. But it is possible that
each speaks from his own point of view. I
will call a witness against you, and that wit-
ness is yourself. For if there were no dis-
pute about doctrines, if you had not roused
the anger of an old man, if he had given you
no reply, what need was there for you, who
do not excel in gifts of speech, to discuss
in a single sermon in the church the
whole circle of doctrine — the Trinity, the
assumption of our Lord's body, the cross, hell, the nature of angels, the condition of
souls, the Saviour's resurrection and our own, and this as taking place on this earth (topics
perhaps omitted in your manuscript) in the
presence of the masses, in the presence, too,
of a man of such distinction ? and to speak
with such perfect assurance and to gallop
through it all without stopping to draw
breath ? What shall we say of the ancient
writers of the Church, who were scarce
able to explain single difficulties in many
volumes ? What of the vessel of election,
1 This probably relates to Rufinus, whose name was men-
tioned by Epiphanius in his letter to John.