LETTERS CXXXIII.-CXXXVIII. 281
all that we can ; we sympathize deeply with
you. And if you will lay a clear and unam-
biguous accusation against any persons in
particular we will appoint suitable judges to
try their cases ; or if you, our highly es- teemed son, think that it is needful for us to
take yet graver and more urgent action, we shall not be slow to do so. Meantime we
have written to our brother bishop John ' ad- vising him to act more considerately, so that
nothing may occur in the church committed
to him which it is his duty to foresee and to
prevent, and that nothing may happen which
may subsequently prove a source of trouble to him.
LETTER CXXXVII.
FROM POPE INNOCENT TO JOHN, BISHOP OF
JERUSALKM.
Innocent censures John for having allowed the Pela-
gians to cause the disturbance at Bethlehem mentioned
in the two preceding letters and exhorts him to be more watchful over his diocese in future. The date of the
letter is A.D. 417. This was the year of the death of
both John and Innocent, and it is probable that John never received the letter.
Innocent to his most highly esteemed
brother John.
The holy virgins Eustochium and Paula* have deplored to me the ravages, murders,
fires and outrages of all kinds, which they
say that the devil has perpetrated in the
district belonging to their church ; for with
wonderful clemency and generosity they have left untold the name and motive of his
human agent. Now although there can be
no doubt as to who is the guilty person ; ' yet you, my brother, ought to have taken
precautions and to have been more careful of
your flock so that no disturbance of the kind
might arise ; for others suffer by your negli-
gence, and you encourage men by it to make
havoc of the Lord's flock till His tender lambs, fleeced and weakened by fire, sword
and persecution, their relations murdered and
dead, are, as we are informed, themselves
scarce alive. Does it not touch your sacred
responsibility as a priest 4 that the devil has shewn himself so powerful against you and
yours ? Against you, I say ; for surely it
speaks ill of your capacity as a priest that a crime so terrible should have been committed
in the pale of your church. Where were
your precautions ? Where, after the blow
had been struck, were your attempts at
1 i.e. John of Jerusalem. See the next letter.
• i.e. Paula the younger, Eustochium's niece, concerning whose education Jerome had written to her mother Laeta ( Let- ter CVII.).
1 The attack was supposed to have been instigated by Pela-
gius.
4 In Jerome's writings this title is often given to bishops. Presbyters are by him rarely so called.
relief ? Where too were your words of com-
fort ? These ladies tell me that up to the
present they have been in a state of too great
apprehension to complain of what they have
already suffered. I should judge more
gravely of the matter had they spoken to me
concerning it more freely than they have.
Beware then, brother, of the wiles of the old
enemy, and in the spirit of a good ruler be
vigilant either to correct or to repress such
evils. For they have reached my ears in the
shape of rumours rather than as specific
accusations. If nothing is done, the law of
the Church on the subject of injuries may
compel the person who has failed to defend
his flock to shew cause for his negligence.
LETTER CXXXVIII.
TO RIPARIUS.
Jerome praises Riparius for his zeal on behalf of the
Catholic faith and for his efforts to put down the Pela-
gians. He then describes the attack made by these
heretics upon the monasteries of Bethlehem. Now, he
is glad to say, they have at last been driven from Pales-
tine. Most of them, that is, for some still linger at
Joppa including one of their chief leaders. The date is A.D. 417.
That you fight Christ's battles against the enemies of the Catholic Faith your own let-
ters have informed me as well as the reports
of many persons, but I am told that you find
the winds contrary and that those who ought
to have been the world's champions have
backed the cause of perdition to each other's ruin. You are to know that in this part of
the world, without any human help and mere-
ly by the decree of Christ, Catiline ' has been driven not only from the capital but from the
borders of Palestine. Lentulus, however,
and many of his fellow-conspirators still lin-
ger to our sorrow in Joppa. I myself have
thought it better to change my abode than to
surrender the true faith ; and have chosen to
leave my pleasant home rather than to suffer
contamination from heresy. For I could not communicate with men who would either
have insisted on my instant submission or
would else have summoned me to support
my opinions by the sword. A good many,
I dare say, have told you the story of my
sufferings and of the vengeance which
Christ's uplifted hand has on my behalf taken upon my enemies. I would beg of you,
therefore, to complete the task which you
have taken up and not, while you are in it,
1 Pelagius would naturally be understood by Catiline, and
Celestius by Lentulus, who was Catiline's lieutenant. But it is known that, after the Synod of Diospolis which acquitted
them, Celestius went to Africa, Ephesus, Constantinopfe, and
Rome, while Pelagius apparently remained in Palestine, where he died.