(β) Jurisdiction
of bishops over bishops. The fully-developed and organised
‘patriarchal’ system does not meet us in the Nicene age.
The bishops of important towns, however, exercise a very real, though
not definable authority over their neighbours. This is especially true
of Imperial residences. The migration of Eusebius to Nicomedia and
afterwards to Constantinople broke through the time-honoured rule of
the Church, but set the precedent commonly followed ever afterwards. In
Egypt, although the name ‘patriarch’ was as yet unheard,
the authority of the Bishop of Alexandria was almost absolute. The name
‘archbishop’ is here used for the first time. It is first
applied apparently to Meletius (Apol. Ar. 71) in his list of
clergy, but at a later date (about 358) to Athanasius in a contemporary
inscription (see p. 564a, note 1). At the beginning of his
episcopate (supra, p. xxxvii.) we find him requested to ordain
in a diocese of Upper Egypt by its bishop. He sends bishops on
deputations (Fest. Ind. xxv., &c.), and exercises ordinary
jurisdiction over bishops and people of Libya and Pentapolis (cf.
reference to Synesius, supr., p. lxii.). This was a condition of
things dating at least from the time of Dionysius (p. 178, note 2). In
particular he had practically the appointment of bishops for all Egypt,
so that in the course of his long episcopate all the Egyptian sees were
manned by his faithful adherents (cf. p. 493). The mention of Dionysius
suggests the question of the relation of the see of Alexandria to that
of Rome, and of the latter to the Church generally. On the former
point, what is necessary will be said in the Introd. to the de Sent.
Dion. With regard to the wider question, Athanasius expresses
reverence for that bishopric ‘because it is an Apostolic
throne,’ and ‘for Rome, because it is the metropolis of
Romania’ (p. 282). That is his only utterance on the subject.
Such reverence ought, he says, to have secured Liberius from the
treatment to which he had been subjected. The language cited excludes
the idea of any divinely-given headship of the Church vested in the
Roman bishop, for his object is to magnify the outrageous conduct of
Constantius and the Arians. Still less can anything be elicited from
the account given by Ath. of the case of the Dionysii, or of his own
relations to successive Roman bishops. He speaks of them as his beloved
brothers and fellow-ministers (e.g., p. 489) and cordially. welcomes
their sympathy and powerful support, without any thought of
jurisdiction. But he furnishes us with materials, in the letter of
Julius, for estimating not his own view of the Roman see, but that held
by its occupant. The origin of the proceedings was the endeavour of the
Easterns to procure recognition at Rome and in the West for their own
nominee to the bishopric of Alexandria. They had requested Julius to
hold a Council, ‘and to be himself the judge if he so
pleased’ (Apol. c. Ar. 20). This was intended to frighten
Athanasius, but not in the least, as the sequel shews, to submit the
decisions of a Council to revision by a single bishop. Julius summoned
a Council as described above (p. xliii.), and at the end of a long
period of delay and controversy sent a letter expressing his view of
the case to the Orientals. This document has been already discussed (p.
xliv.). It forms an important landmark in the history of papal claims,
standing at least as significantly in contrast with those of the
successors of Julius, as with those of his predecessors.