SECT. VIII.
Showing how Mr. W. often begs the question himself.
The question is certainly begged in that argument which Mr. W. espouses and defends,
viz. That the Lord’s supper has a proper tendency to promote men’s conversion. In the
prosecution of the argument Mr. W. implicitly yields, that it is not the apparent natural
tendency alone, that is of any force to prove the point; but the apparent tendency under this
circumstance, that there in no express prohibition. And thus it is allowed, that in the case of
express prohibition with respect to the scandalous and morally insincere, no seeming
tendency in the nature of the thing proves the ordinance to be intended for the conviction
and conversion of such. So that it is a thing supposed in this argument, that all morally in-
sincere persons are expressly forbidden, but unsanctified persons not so. Now when it is
supposed, that morally insincere persons are expressly forbidden, the thing meant cannot
be, that they are forbidden in those very words; for no such prohibition is to be found: nor
are men that live in sodomy, bestiality, and witchcraft, any where expressly forbidden in
this sense. But the thing intended must be, that they are very evidently forbidden, by plain
implication, or consequence. But then the whole weight of the argument lies in this suppos-
ition, that unsanctified persons are not also plainly and evidently forbidden; which is the
very point in question. And therefore to make this the ground of an argument to prove this
point, is a manifest begging the question. And what Mr. W. says to the contrary, (p. 127. a.)
517
that Mr. Stoddard had proved this point before, avails nothing: for let it be never so much
proved before, yet, after all, to take this very point and make use of it as a further argument
to prove itself, is certainly begging the question. The notion of bringing a new argument is
bringing additional proof: but to take a certain point, supposed to be already proved, to
prove itself with over again, certainly does not add any thing to the evidence.
Mr. W. says, my supposing unconverted persons, as such, to be as evidently forbidden,
as scandalous persons, is as much begging the question. I answer, So it would be, if I made
that point an argument to prove itself with, after Mr. W.’s manner. But this is far from being
the case in fact.
And the question is again most certainly begged, in that other thing said to support this
argument, viz. That though the Lord’s supper may seem to have a tendency to convert
scandalous sinners, yet there is another ordinance appointed for that. Here the meaning
must be, that there is another ordinance exclusive of the Lord’s supper; otherwise it is
nothing to the purpose. For they do not deny but that there are other ordinances for the
conversion of sinners, who are morally sincere, as well as of those who are scandalous. But
the question is, Whether other ordinances are appointed for their conversion exclusive of
the Lord’s supper; or, whether the Lord’s supper be one ordinance appointed for their con-
version? This is the grand point in question. And to take this point as the foundation of an
SECTION VIII. Mr. W. begs the question.
1991
SECTION VIII. Mr. W. begs the question.