Now it may serve to make them understand what
they are saying, to ask them first this, what in fact a son is, and of
what is that name significant Vid.
Orat. i. §38. The controversy turned on the question what
was meant by the word ‘Son.’ Though the Arians would not
allow with the Catholics that our Lord was Son by nature, and
maintained that the word implied a beginning of existence, they
did not dare to say that He was Son merely in the sense in which we are
sons, though, as Athan. contends, they necessarily tended to this
conclusion, directly they receded from the Catholic view. Thus Arius
said that He was a creature, ‘but not as one of the
creatures.’ Orat. ii. §19. Valens at Ariminum said
the same, Jerom. adv. Lucifer. 18. Hilary says, that not daring
directly to deny that He was God, the Arians merely asked
‘whether He was a Son.’ de Trin. viii. 3. Athanasius
remarks upon this reluctance to speak out, challenging them to present
‘the heresy naked,’ de Sent. Dionys. 2. init.
‘No one,’ he says elsewhere, ‘puts a light under a
bushel; let them shew the world their heresy naked.’ Ep.
Æg. 18. vid. ibid. 10. In like manner, Basil says that (though
Arius was really like Eunomius, in faith, contr. Eunom. i. 4)
Aetius his master was the first to teach openly (φανερῶς), that the Father’s substance was unlike,
ἀνόμοιος, the Son’s. ibid. i. 1. Epiphanius Hær. 76 p.
949. seems to say that the elder Arians held the divine generation in a
sense in which Aetius did not, that is, they were not so consistent and
definite as he. Athan. goes on to mention some of the attempts of the
Arians to find some theory short of orthodoxy, yet short of that
extreme heresy, on the other hand, which they felt ashamed to
avow.. In truth, Divine
Scripture acquaints us with a double sense of this word:—one
which Moses sets before us in the Law, ‘When ye shall hearken to
the voice of the Lord thy God, to keep all His commandments which I
command thee this day, to do that which is right in the eyes of the
Lord thy God, ye are children of the Lord your God Deut. xiii. 18; xiv.
1.;’ as also in the Gospel, John says,
‘But as many as received Him, to them gave He power to become the
sons of God John. i. 12.:’—and the other sense, that
in which Isaac is son of Abraham, and Jacob of Isaac, and the
Patriarchs of Jacob. Now in which of these two senses do they
understand the Son of God that they relate such fables as the
foregoing? for I feel sure they will issue in the same irreligion with
Eusebius and his fellows.