And on other accounts also it
may be called safe to let alone the Divine essence, as unspeakable, and
beyond the scope of human reasoning. For the desire of investigating
what is obscure and tracing out hidden things by the operation of human
reasoning gives an entrance to false no less than to true notions,
inasmuch as he who aspires to know the unknown will not always arrive
at truth, but may also conceive of falsehood itself as truth. But the
disciple of the Gospels and of Prophecy believes that He Who is, is;
both from what he has learnt from the sacred writers, and from the
harmony of things which do appear, and from the works of Providence.
But what He is and how—leaving this as a useless and unprofitable
speculation, such a disciple will open no door to falsehood against
truth. For in speculative enquiry fallacies readily find place. But
where speculation is entirely at rest, the necessity of error is
precluded. And that this is a true account of the case, may be seen if
we consider how it is that heresies in the churches have wandered off
into many and various opinions in regard to God, men deceiving
themselves as they are swayed by one mental impulse or another; and how
these very men with whom our treatise is concerned have slipped into
such a pit of profanity. Would it not have been safer for all,
following the counsel of wisdom, to abstain from searching into such
deep matters, and in peace and quietness to keep inviolate the pure
deposit of the faith? But since, in fact, human nothingness has
commenced intruding recklessly into matters that are above
comprehension, and supporting by dogmatic teaching the figments of
their vain imagination, there has sprung up in consequence a whole host
of enemies to the truth, and among them these very men who are the
subject of this treatise; dogmatizers of deceit who seek to limit the
Divine Being, and all but openly idolize their own imagination, in that
they deify the idea expressed by this “ungeneracy” of
theirs, as not being only in a certain relation discernible in the
Divine nature, but as being itself God, or the essence of God. Yet
perchance they would have done better to look to the sacred company of
the Prophets and Patriarchs, to whom “at sundry times, and in
divers manners Heb. i. 1.,” the Word of
truth spake, and, next in order, those who were eye-witnesses and
ministers of the word, that they might give honour due to the claims on
their belief of the things attested by the Holy Spirit Himself, and
abide within the limits of their teaching and knowledge, and not
venture on themes which are not comprehended in the canon of the sacred
writers. For those writers, by revealing God, so long unknown to human
life by reason of the prevalence of idolatry, and making Him known to
men, both from the wonders which manifest themselves in His works, and
from the names which express the manifold variety of His power, lead
men, as by the hand, to the understanding of the Divine nature, making
known to them the bare grandeur of the thought of God; while the
question of His essence, as one which it is impossible to grasp, and
which bears no fruit to the curious enquirer, they dismiss without any
attempt at its solution. For whereas they have set forth respecting all
other things, that they were created, the heaven, the earth, the sea,
times, ages, and the creatures that are therein, but what each is in
itself, and how and whence, on these points they are silent; so, too,
concerning God Himself, they exhort men to “believe that He is,
and that He is a rewarder of them that diligently seek Him Heb. xi. 6.,” but in regard to His nature, as
being above every name, they neither name it nor concern themselves
about it. For if we have learned any names expressive of the knowledge
of God, all these are related and have analogy to such names as denote
human characteristics. For as they who would indicate some person
unknown by marks of recognition speak of him as of good parentage and
descent, if such happen to be the case, or as
distinguished for his riches or his worth, or as in the prime of life,
or of such or such stature, and in so speaking they do not set forth
the nature of the person indicated, but give certain notes of
recognition (for neither advantages of birth, nor of wealth, nor of
reputation, nor of age, constitute the man; they are considered, simply
as being observable in the man), thus too the expressions of Holy
Scripture devised for the glory of God set forth one or another of the
things which are declared concerning Him, each inculcating some special
teaching. For by these expressions we are taught either His power, or
that He admits not of deterioration, or that He is without cause and
without limit, or that He is supreme above all things, or, in short,
something, be it what it may, respecting Him. But His very essence, as
not to be conceived by the human intellect or expressed in words, this
it has left untouched as a thing not to be made the subject of curious
enquiry, ruling that it be revered in silence, in that it forbids the
investigation of things too deep for us, while it enjoins the duty of
being slow to utter any word before God. And therefore, whosoever
searches the whole of Revelation will find therein no doctrine of the
Divine nature, nor indeed of anything else that has a substantial
existence, so that we pass our lives in ignorance of much, being
ignorant first of all of ourselves, as men, and then of all things
besides. For who is there who has arrived at a comprehension of his own
soul? Who is acquainted with its very essence, whether it is material
or immaterial, whether it is purely incorporeal, or whether it exhibits
anything of a corporeal character; how it comes into being, how it is
composed, whence it enters into the body, how it departs from it, or
what means it possesses to unite it to the nature of the body; how,
being intangible and without form, it is kept within its own sphere,
what difference exists among its powers, how one and the same soul, in
its eager curiosity to know the things which are unseen, soars above
the highest heavens, and again, dragged down by the weight of the body,
falls back on material passions, anger and fear, pain and pleasure,
pity and cruelty, hope and memory, cowardice and audacity, friendship
and hatred, and all the contraries that are produced in the faculties
of the soul? Observing which things, who has not fancied that he has a
sort of populace of souls crowded together in himself, each of the
aforesaid passions differing widely from the rest, and, where it
prevails, holding lordship over them all, so that even the rational
faculty falls under and is subject to the predominating power of such
forces, and contributes its own co-operation to such impulses, as to a
despotic lord? What word, then, of the inspired Scripture has taught us
the manifold and multiform character of what we understand in speaking
of the soul? Is it a unity composed of them all, and, if so, what is it
that blends and harmonizes things mutually opposed, so that many things
become one, while each element, taken by itself, is shut up in the soul
as in some ample vessel? And how is it that we have not the perception
of them all as being involved in it, being at one and the same time
confident and afraid, at once hating and loving and feeling in
ourselves the working as well of all other emotions confused and
intermingled; but, on the contrary, take knowledge only of their
alternate control, when one of them prevails, the rest remaining
quiescent? What in short is this composition and arrangement, and this
capacious void within us, such that to each is assigned its own post,
as though hindered by middle walls of partition from holding
intercourse with its neighbour? And then again what account has
explained whether passion is the fundamental essence of the soul, or
fear, or any of the other elements which I have mentioned; and what
emotions are unsubstantial? For if these have an independent
subsistence, then, as I have said, there is comprehended in ourselves
not one soul, but a collection of souls, each of them occupying its
distinct position as a particular and individual soul. But if we must
suppose these to be a kind of emotion without subsistence, how can that
which has no essential existence exercise lordship over us, having
reduced us as it were to slave under whichsoever of these things may
have happened to prevail? And if the soul is something that thought
only can grasp, how can that which is manifold and composite be
contemplated as such, when such an object ought to be contemplated by
itself, independently of these bodily qualities? Then, as to the
soul’s power of growth, of desire, of nutrition, of change, and
the fact that all the bodily powers are nourished, while feeling does
not extend through all, but, as in things without life, some of our
members are destitute of feeling, the bones for example, the
cartilages, the nails, the hair, all of which take nourishment, but do
not feel,—tell me who is there that understands this only
half-complete operation of the soul as to these? And why do I speak of
the soul? Even the inquiry as to that thing in the flesh itself which
assumes all the corporeal qualities has not been pursued to any
definite result. For if any one has made a mental analysis of that
which is seen into its component parts, and, having stripped the object
of its qualities, has attempted to consider it by itself, I fail to see
what will have been left for investigation. For when you take from a body
its colour, its shape, its degree of resistance, its weight, its
quantity, its position, its forces active or passive, its relation to
other objects, what remains, that can still be called a body, we can
neither see of ourselves, nor are we taught it by Scripture. But how
can he who is ignorant of himself take knowledge of anything that is
above himself? And if a man is familiarized with such ignorance of
himself, is he not plainly taught by the very fact not to be astonished
at any of the mysteries that are without? Wherefore also, of the
elements of the world, we know only so much by our senses as to enable
us to receive what they severally supply for our living. But we possess
no knowledge of their substance, nor do we count it loss to be ignorant
of it. For what does it profit me to inquire curiously into the nature
of fire, how it is struck out, how it is kindled, how, when it has
caught hold of the fuel supplied to it, it does not let it go till it
has devoured and consumed its prey; how the spark is latent in the
flint, how steel, cold as it is to the touch, generates fire, how
sticks rubbed together kindle flame, how water shining in the sun
causes a flash; and then again the cause of its upward tendency, its
power of incessant motion?—Putting aside all which curious
questions and investigations, we give heed only to the subservience of
this fire to life, seeing that he who avails himself of its service
fares no worse than he who busies himself with inquiries into its
nature.