Now that this is the meaning to
which he tends in his conception concerning the Only-begotten will
become more plain by considering the language he employs touching the
Only-begotten Himself, which is as follows. “We believe also in
the Son of God, the Only-begotten God, the first-born of all creation,
very Son, not ungenerate, verily begotten before the worlds, named Son
not without being begotten before He existed, coming into being before
all creation, not uncreate.” I think that the mere reading of his
exposition of his faith is quite sufficient to render its impiety plain
without any investigation on our part. For though he calls Him
“first-born,” yet that he may not raise any doubt in his
readers’ minds as to His not being created, he immediately adds
the words, “not uncreate,” lest if the natural significance
of the term “Son” were apprehended by his readers, any
pious conception concerning Him might find place in their minds. It is
for this reason that after at first confessing Him to be Son of God and Only-begotten God, he proceeds at once, by
what he adds, to pervert the minds of his readers from their devout
belief to his heretical notions. For he who hears the titles “Son
of God” and “Only-begotten God” is of necessity
lifted up to the loftier kind of assertions respecting the Son, led
onward by the significance of these terms, inasmuch as no difference of
nature is introduced by the use of the title “God” and by
the significance of the term “Son.” For how could He Who is
truly the Son of God and Himself God be conceived as something else
differing from the nature of the Father? But that godly conceptions may
not by these names be impressed beforehand on the hearts of his
readers, he forthwith calls Him “the first-born of all creation,
named Son, not without being begotten before He existed, coming into
being before all creation, not uncreate.” Let us linger a little
while, then, over his argument, that the miscreant may be shown to be
holding out his first statements to people merely as a bait to induce
them to receive the poison that he sugars over with phrases of a pious
tendency, as it were with honey. Who does not know how great is the
difference in signification between the term
“only-begotten” and “first-born?” For
“first-born” implies brethren, and
“only-begotten” implies that there are no other brethren.
Thus the “first-born” is not “only-begotten,”
for certainly “first-born” is the first-born among
brethren, while he who is “only-begotten” has no brother:
for if he were numbered among brethren he would not be only-begotten.
And moreover, whatever the essence of the brothers of the first-born
is, the same is the essence of the first-born himself. Nor is this all
that is signified by the title, but also that the first-born and those
born after him draw their being from the same source, without the
first-born contributing at all to the birth of those that come after
him: so that hereby Hereby,
i.e. by the use of the term πρωτότοκος
as applicable to the Divinity of the Son. is maintained the
falsehood of that statement of John, which affirms that “all
things were made by Him S. John i. 3.” For if He is
first-born, He differs from those born after Him only by priority in
time, while there must be some one else by Whom the power to be at all
is imparted alike to Him and to the rest. But that we may not by our
objections give any unfair opponent ground for an insinuation that we
do not receive the inspired utterances of Scripture, we will first set
before our readers our own view about these titles, and then leave it
to their judgment which is the better.