With this agrees Zonaras, whose remarks are worthy of
consideration. On this whole subject of the commutation of the
primitive penance and of the rise of the modern indulgences of the
Roman Church Van Espen has written at length in his excursus De
Indulgentiis (Jure Eccles., P. I. i., Tit. vij.) in which he
assigns the change to the end of the XIth century, and remarks that its introduction
caused the “no small collapse of penitential
discipline.” The reader is referred
also to Amort, De Origine, progressu, valore ac fructu
Indulgentiarum, and to the article “Ablass” in the
Kirchen Lexicon of Wetzer and Welte. Also for the English
reader to T. L. Green, D.D., Indulgences, Absolutions, and Tax
tables, etc. Some of the difficulties which Roman theologians
experience in explaining what are called “Plenary
Indulgences” are set forth by Dr. Littledale in his Plain
Reasons against joining the Church of Rome, in which the matter is
discussed in the usual witty, and unscrupulous fashion of that
brilliant writer. But while this remark is just, it should also
be remarked that after the exaggeration is removed there yet remains a
difficulty of the most serious character.