Why then is the majesty of the
Spirit curtailed by such arguments as these? For there is
nothing which can be the cause of producing in him deviation by excess or
defect from conceptions such as befit the Godhead, nor, since all these
are by Holy Scripture predicated equally of the Son and of the Holy
Spirit, can he inform us wherein he discerns inequality to exist. But
he launches his blasphemy against the Holy Ghost in its naked form,
ill-prepared and unsupported by any consecutive argument. “Nor
yet ranked,” he says, “with any other: for He has gone
above ἀναβέβηκε: the word apparently is intended by Eunomius to have the
force of “transcended”; Gregory, later on, criticizes its
employment in this sense. all the creatures that came into being by the
instrumentality of the Son in mode of being, and nature, and glory, and
knowledge, as the first and noblest work of the Only-begotten, the
greatest and most glorious.” I will leave, however, to others the
task of ridiculing the bad taste and surplusage of his style, thinking
as I do that it is unseemly for the gray hairs of age, when dealing
with the argument before us, to make vulgarity of expression an
objection against one who is guilty of impiety. I will just add to my
investigation this remark. If the Spirit has “gone above”
all the creations of the Son, (for I will use his own ungrammatical and
senseless phrase, or rather, to make things clearer, I will present his
idea in my own language) if he transcends all things wrought by the
Son, the Holy Spirit cannot be ranked with the rest of the creation;
and if, as Eunomius says, he surpasses them by virtue of priority of
birth, he must needs confess, in the case of the rest of creation, that
the objects which are first in order of production are more to be
esteemed than those which come after them. Now the creation of the
irrational animals was prior to that of man. Accordingly he will of
course declare that the irrational nature is more honourable than
rational existence. So too, according to the argument of Eunomius, Cain
will be proved superior to Abel, in that he was before him in time of
birth, and so the stars will be shown to be lower and of less
excellence than all the things that grow out of the earth; for these
last sprang from the earth on the third day, and all the stars are
recorded by Moses to have been created on the fourth. Well, surely no
one is such a simpleton as to infer that the grass of the earth is more
to be esteemed than the marvels of the sky, on the ground of its
precedence in time, or to award the meed to Cain over Abel, or to place
below the irrational animals man who came into being later than they.
So there is no sense in our author’s contention that the nature
of the Holy Spirit is superior to that of the creatures that came into
being subsequently, on the ground that He came into being before they
did. And now let us see what he who separates Him from fellowship with
the Son is prepared to concede to the glory of the Spirit: “For
he too,” he says, “being one, and first and alone, and
surpassing all the creations of the Son in essence and dignity of
nature, accomplishing every operation and all teaching according to the
good pleasure of the Son, being sent by Him, and receiving from Him,
and declaring to those who are instructed, and guiding into
truth.” He speaks of the Holy Ghost as “accomplishing every
operation and all teaching.” What operation? Does he mean that
which the Father and the Son execute, according to the word of the Lord
Himself Who “hitherto worketh S. John v. 17”
man’s salvation, or does he mean some other? For if His work is
that named, He has assuredly the same power and nature as Him Who works
it, and in such an one difference of kind from Deity can have no place.
For just as, if anything should perform the functions of fire, shining
and warming in precisely the same way, it is itself certainly fire, so
if the Spirit does the works of the Father, He must assuredly be
acknowledged to be of the same nature with Him. If on the other hand He
operates something else than our salvation, and displays His operation
in a contrary direction, He will thereby be proved to be of a different
nature and essence. But Eunomius’ statement itself bears witness
that the Spirit quickeneth in like manner with the Father and the Son.
Accordingly, from the identity of operations it results assuredly that
the Spirit is not alien from the nature of the Father and the Son. And
to the statement that the Spirit accomplishes the operation and
teaching of the Father according to the good pleasure of the Son we
assent. For the community of nature gives us warrant that the will of
the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost is one, and thus, if the
Holy Spirit wills that which seems good to the Son, the community of
will clearly points to unity of essence. But he goes on, “being
sent by Him, and receiving from Him, and declaring to those who are
instructed, and guiding into truth.” If he had not previously
said what he has concerning the Spirit, the reader would surely have
supposed that these words applied to some human teacher. For to receive
a mission is the same thing as to be sent, and to have nothing of
one’s own, but to receive of the free favour of him who gives the
mission, and to minister his words to those who are under instruction,
and to be a guide into truth for those that are astray. All these
things, which Eunomius is good enough to allow to the Holy Spirit,
belong to the present pastors and teachers of the Church,—to be
sent, to receive, to announce, to teach, to suggest the truth. Now, as he had
said above “He is one, and first, and alone, and surpassing
all,” had he but stopped there, he would have appeared as a
defender of the doctrines of truth. For He Who is indivisibly
contemplated in the One is most truly One, and first Who is in the
First, and alone Who is in the Only One. For as the spirit of man that
is in him, and the man himself, are but one man, so also the Spirit of
God which is in Him, and God Himself, would properly be termed One God,
and First and Only, being incapable of separation from Him in Whom He
is. But as things are, with his addition of his profane phrase,
“surpassing all the creatures of the Son,” he produces
turbid confusion by assigning to Him Who “breatheth where He
willeth S. John iii. 8,” and “worketh all in all 1 Cor. xii. 6.,” a mere superiority in comparison with
the rest of created things.