§4.
Editions and
Versions
.
The original Greek of
Eusebius’
History
has been published in many
editions.
1. The
editio princeps
is
that of Robert Stephanus, which appeared at Paris in 1544, and again,
with a few changes, and with the Latin translation of Christophorsonus
and the notes of Suffridus Petrus, at Geneva in 1612.
2. Henr. Valesius (de Valois)
published his first edition of the Greek text, with a new Latin
translation and with copious critical and explanatory notes, at Paris
in 1659. His edition was reprinted at Mainz in 1672, but the reprint is
full of errors. In 1677, after Valesius’ death, a revised edition
was issued at Paris, which in 1695 was reprinted with some corrections
at Amsterdam. In 1720 Valesius’ edition of Eusebius, together
with his edition of Socrates, Sozomen, and the other Greek historians,
was republished at Cambridge by William Reading, in three folio
volumes. This is the best edition of Valesius, the commentary being
supplemented by
ms.
notes which he had left
among his papers, and increased by large additions from other writers
under the head of
Variorum
. A reprint of Reading’s edition
was issued in 1746–1748, but according to Heinichen it is not as
accurate as that of 1720. For the elucidation of Eusebius’
History
we owe more to Valesius than to any other man. His
edition of the text was an immense advance upon that of Stephanus, and
has formed the basis of all subsequent editions, while his notes are a
perfect storehouse of information from which all annotators of Eusebius
have extensively drawn. Migne’s edition (
Opera
, II.
45–906) is a reprint of Valesius’ edition of
1659.
3. F. A. Stroth (Halle, 1779). A
new edition of the Greek text, of which, however, only the first volume
appeared, comprising Books I.-VII.
4. E. Zimmermann
(Frankfort-on-the-Main, 1822). A new edition of the Greek text,
containing also the Latin translation of Valesius, and a few critical
notes.
5. F. A. Heinichen (Leipzig,
1827 and 1828). An edition of the Greek text in three volumes, with a
reprint of the entire commentary of Valesius, and with the addition of
Variorum
notes. The critical apparatus, printed in the third
volume, is very meager. A few valuable excursuses close the work. Forty
years later Heinichen published a second edition of the
History
in his
Eusebii Pamphili Scripta Historica
(Lips.
1868–1870, 3 vols.). The first volume contains the Greek text of
the
History
, with valuable prolegomena, copious critical
apparatus and very useful indices; the second volume contains the
Vita Constantini
, the
Panegyricus
or
De laudibus
Constantini
, and Constantine’s
Oratio ad Sanctorum
coetum
, also accompanied with critical apparatus and indices; the
third volume contains an extensive commentary upon the works included
in the first two volumes, together with twenty-nine valuable
excursuses. This entirely supersedes the first, and is on the whole the
most complete and useful edition of the
History
which we have.
The editor made diligent use of the labors of his predecessors,
especially of Laemmer’s. He did no independent work, however, in
the way of collecting material for the criticism of the text, and was
deficient in critical judgment. As a consequence his text has often to
be amended on the basis of the variant readings, which he gives with
great fullness. His commentary is made up largely of quotations from
Valesius and other writers, and is valuable for the material it thus
contains as well as for its references to other works. It labors under
the same incompleteness, however, that mars Valesius’ commentary,
and, moreover, contains almost nothing of independent value.
6. E. Burton (Oxford, 1838). The
Greek text in two volumes, with the translation of Valesius and with
critical apparatus; and again in 1845, with the critical apparatus
omitted, but with the notes of Valesius, Heinichen and others added.
Burton made large contributions to the criticism of the text, and had
he lived to superintend the issue of the second edition, would perhaps
have succeeded in giving us a better text than any which we now
possess, for he was a far more
sagacious critic than
Heinichen. As it is, his edition is marred by numerous imperfections,
largely caused by the inaccuracy of those who collated
mss.
for him. His text, with the translation, notes, and
critical apparatus omitted, was reprinted by Bright at Oxford in 1872,
and again in 1881, in a single volume. This is a very handy edition,
and for school use is unsurpassed. The typography is superb, and the
admirable plan is followed of discarding quotation marks and printing
all citations in smaller type, thus making plain to the eye at a glance
what is Eusebius’ own and what is another’s. The text is
preceded by a very interesting and graphic life of the
historian.
7. Schwegler (Tübingen,
1852, in one volume). The Greek text with critical apparatus, but
without translation and notes. An accurate and useful
edition.
8. Laemmer (Schaffhausen,
1859–1862). The Greek text in one volume, with extensive critical
apparatus, but without explanatory notes. Laemmer had unusual
opportunities for collecting material, and has made larger additions to
the critical apparatus than any one else. His edition was issued,
however, in a most slovenly manner, and swarms with mistakes. Great
care should therefore be exercised in the use of it.
9. Finally must be mentioned the
text of Dindorf (Lips. 1871), which is published in the Teubner series,
and like most of the volumes of that series is handy and convenient,
but of little value to the critical student.
There are few writings of the
Fathers which more sadly need and more richly deserve a new critical
edition than the
History
of Eusebius. The material for the
formation of a reliable text is extensive and accessible, but editors
have contented themselves too much in the past with the results of
their predecessors’ labors, and unfortunately those labors have
not always been accurate and thorough. As a consequence a new and more
careful collation of most of the
mss.
of the
original, together with those of Rufinus’ translation, must lie
at the foundation of any new work which is to be done in this line. The
publication of the Syriac version will doubtless furnish much valuable
material which the next editor of the
History
will be able to
use to advantage. Anything less than such a thorough work as I have
indicated will be of little worth. Unless the new edition be based upon
extensive and independent labors, it will be little if any improvement
upon that of Heinichen. It is to be hoped that a critical text, up to
the standard of those of some other patristic works which we already
possess, may yet be issued, which shall give us this, one of the
noblest productions of the ancient Church, in a fitting and
satisfactory form.
Translations of Eusebius’
History
are very numerous. Probably the earliest of all is the
ancient Syriac version which is preserved in great part in two
mss.
, one of which is at St. Petersburg and contains
the entire
History
with the exception of Book VI. and large
portions of Books V. and VII. The
ms.
is dated
462
a.d.
(see Wright’s description of it
in his
Catalogue of the Syriac
mss.
in the
British Museum acquired since the year 1838
, Part III. p. xv. sq.).
The second
ms.
is in the British Museum, and
contains Books I.–V., with some mutilations at the beginning of
the first book. The
ms.
dates from the sixth
century (see Wright’s description of it in his
Catalogue
,
p. 1039). From these
mss.
Wright was engaged
in preparing an edition of the Syriac, which remained unfinished at the
time of his death. Whether he left his work in such shape that it can
soon be issued by some one else I have not yet learned. The version was
probably made at a very early date, possibly within the lifetime of
Eusebius himself, though of that we can have no assurance. I understand
that it confirms in the main the Greek text as now printed in our best
editions.
The original Latin version was
made by Rufinus in the early years of the fifth century. He translated
only nine books, and added to them two of his own, in which he brought
the history down to the death of Theodosius the Great. He allowed
himself his customary license in translating, and yet, although his
version is by no means exact, it is one of our best sources for a
knowledge of the true text of Eusebius, for it is possible, in many
doubtful cases where our
mss.
are hopelessly
divided, to ascertain from his rendering what stood in the original
Greek.
The
version of Rufinus had a large circulation, and became in the Western
Church a substitute for the original throughout the Middle Ages. It was
first printed, according to Fabricius (
ib
. p. 59), in 1476 at
Rome, afterward a great many times there and elsewhere. The first
critical edition, which still remains the best, is that of Cacciari
(Rome, 1740), which has become rare, and is very difficult to find. A
new edition is a great desideratum. An important work upon
Rufinus’ version is Kimmel’s
De Rufino Eusebii
Interprete
, Geræ, 1838.
A new Latin translation, by
Wolfgang Musculus, was published in Basle, in 1549, and again in 1557,
1562, and 1611, according to Fabricius (
Bibl. Gr
. VI. p. 60). I
have myself seen only the edition of 1562.
Still another Latin version,
from the hand of Christophorsonus, was published at Louvain in 1570.
This is the only edition of Christophorsonus which I have seen, but I
have notices of Cologne editions of 1570, 1581 and 1612, and of a Paris
edition of 1571. According to Fabricius the Paris edition, and
according to Brunnet the Cologne edition of 1581, contain the notes of
Suffridus Petrus. A revision of Christophorsonus’ version is said
by Crusè to have been published by Curterius, but I have not seen
it, nor am I aware of its date.
Another translation, by
Grynæus, was published at Basle in 1611. This is the only edition
of Grynæus’ version which I have seen, and I find in it no
reference to an earlier one. I have been informed, however, that an
edition appeared in 1591. Hanmer seems to imply, in his preface, that
Grynæus’ version is only a revision of that of Musculus, and
if that were so we should have to identify the 1611 edition with the
1611 edition of Musculus mentioned by Fabricius (see above). I am able,
however, to find no hint in Grynæus’ edition itself that his
version is a revision of that of Musculus.
The translation of Valesius,
which was first published in 1659 (see above), was a great improvement
upon all that had preceded it, and has been many times reprinted in
other editions of Eusebius, as well as in his own.
The first German translation was
published by Caspar Hedio. The date of publication is given by
Fabricius as 1545, but the copy which I have seen is dated 1582, and
contains no reference to an earlier edition. It comprises only nine
books of Eusebius, supplemented by the two of Rufinus. The title runs
as follows:
Chronica, das ist: wahrhaftige Beschreibunge aller alten
Christlichen Kirchen;
zum ersten, die
hist. eccles
. Eusebii
Pamphili Cæsariensis, Eilff Bücher; zum andern, die
hist.
eccles. tripartita
Sozomeni, Socratis und Theodoreti, Zwölff
Bücher; zum dritten die
hist. eccles
. sampt andern
treffenlichen Geschichten, die zuvor in Teutschef Sprache wenig gelesen
sind, auch Zwölff Bücher. Von der Zeit an da die
hist.
eccles. tripartita
aufhöret: das ist, von der jarzal an,
vierhundert nach Christi geburt, biss auff das jar
MDXLV
, durch D. Caspar Hedion zu Strassburg verteutscht
und zusamen getragen. Getruckt zu Franckfurt am Mayn, im jar
1582.
A second German translation of
the entire
History
(with the exception of the
Martyrs of
Palestine
, and the
Oration on the Building of the Churches
,
X. 4), together with the
Life of Constantine
, was published by
F. A. Stroth in Quedlinburg in 1777, in two volumes. Stroth prefaced
the translation with a very valuable Life of Eusebius, and added a
number of excellent notes of his own. The translation is reasonably
accurate.
A much more elegant German
version (including the
Oration
, but omitting the
Martyrs of
Palestine
) was published by Closs in Stuttgart in 1839, in one
volume. This is in my opinion the best translation of the
History
that exists. Its style is admirable, but pure German
idiom is sometimes secured at the expense of faithfulness. In fact the
author has aimed to produce a free, rather than a literal translation,
and has occasionally allowed himself to depart too far from the
original. A few brief notes, most of them taken from Valesius or
Stroth, accompany the translation.
More recently a German
translation has been published by Stigloher (Kempten, 1880) in the
Kempten
Bibliothek der Kirchenväter
. It purports to be a
new translation, but is practically
nothing more than a poorly
revised edition of Closs’ version. The changes which are made are
seldom improvements.
Fabricius mentions a French
translation by Claudius Seysselius, but does not give the date of it,
and I have not myself seen it. Dr. Richardson, however, informs me that
he has a copy of this translation (which is from the Latin, not from
the Greek) bearing the following title:
L’Histoire
ecclesiastique translatie de Latin au Français, par M. Claude de
Seyssel, evesque lors de Marseille, et depuis archevesque de
Thurin
. Paris, 1532 [or ’33], fº. He informs me also
that there exist editions of the years 1537 and 1567.
More than a century later
appeared a new French translation by Louis Cousin, bearing the
following title:
Histoire de l’Eglise écrité par
Eusèbe Césarée, Socrate, Sozomène, Theodoret et
Evagre, avec l’abrégé de Philostorge par Photius, et de
Théodore par Nicephore Calliste
. Paris, 1675–1676. 4
vol. 4º. Another edition appeared in Holland in 1686, 5 vol.
12º.
The first English translation
was made by Hanmer, and was issued in 1584, and, according to
Crusè, passed through five editions. The fourth edition, which
lies before me, was published in London in 1636. The volume contains
the
Histories
of Eusebius, of Socrates, and of Evagrius;
Dorotheus’
Lives
, and Eusebius’
Life of
Constantine
.
Another translation is said by
Crusè to have been published about a century later by T. Shorting,
and to be a decided improvement upon that of Hanmer. I have seen no
copy bearing Shorting’s name, but have examined an anonymous
translation which bears the following title:
The Ecclesiastical
History of Eusebius Pamphilus in ten books
. Made into English from
that edition set forth by Valesius, and printed at Paris in the year
1659; together with Valesius’ notes on the said historian, which
are done into English and set at their proper place in the margin.
Hereto also is annexed an account of the life and writings of the
aforesaid historian, collected by Valesius and rendered into English.
Cambridge: John Hayes, 1683. This is evidently the translation of
Shorting referred to by Crusè, for it answers perfectly the
description which he gives of it.
An abridgment of this version,
made by Parker, is mentioned both by Fabricius (
ib
. p. 62) and
by Crusè, but I have not myself seen it. Fabricius gives its date
as 1703, and Dr. Richardson informs me that he has seen an edition
bearing the date 1729, and that he has a note of another published in
1703 or 1720.
The latest English translation
was made by the Rev. C. F. Crusè, an American Episcopalian of
German descent, and was published first in Philadelphia in 1833, with a
translation, by Parker, of Valesius’
Life of Eusebius
prefixed. It has been reprinted a great many times both in England and
America, and is included in Bohn’s Ecclesiastical Library. In
Bohn’s edition are printed a few scattered notes from
Valesius’ commentary, and in some other editions an historical
account of the Council of Nicæa, by Isaac Boyle, is added. The
translation is an improvement upon its predecessors, but is
nevertheless very faulty and unsatisfactory. The translator is not
thoroughly at home in the English, and, moreover, his version is marred
by many serious omissions and interpolations which reveal an
inexcusable degree of carelessness on his part.