150
Chapter XXIII.—Narrative Concerning John the Apostle.
1. At that time the apostle and evangelist John, the one whom Jesus loved, was still living
in Asia, and governing the churches of that region, having returned after the death of
Domitian from his exile on the island.740
2. And that he was still alive at that time741 may be established by the testimony of two
witnesses. They should be trustworthy who have maintained the orthodoxy of the Church;
and such indeed were Irenæus and Clement of Alexandria.742
3. The former in the second book of his work Against Heresies, writes as follows:743
“And all the elders that associated with John the disciple of the Lord in Asia bear witness
that John delivered it to them. For he remained among them until the time of Trajan.”744
740 See chap. 1, note 6, and chap. 18, note 1.
741 That is, at the beginning of the reign of Trajan.
742 The test of a man’s trustworthiness in Eusebius’ mind—and not in his alone—was his orthodoxy. Irenæus
has always been looked upon as orthodox, and so was Clement, in the early Church, which reckoned him among
the saints. His name, however, was omitted in the Martyrology issued by Clement VIII., on the ground that his
orthodoxy was open to suspicion.
743 Irenæus, Adv. Hær. II. 22. 5.
744 It is in this immediate connection that Irenæus makes the extraordinary assertion, founding it upon the
testimony of those who were with John in Asia, that Christ lived to the age of forty or fifty years. A statement
occurring in connection with such a palpably false report might well fall under suspicion; but the fact of John’s
continuance at Ephesus until the time of Trajan is supported by other passages, and there is no reason to doubt
it (cf. chap. 1, note 6). Irenæus himself repeats the statement as a well-known fact, in III. 3, 4 (quoted just below).
It may also be said that the opinion as to Christ’s age is founded upon subjective grounds (cf. the preceding
paragraph of Irenæus) and upon a mistaken interpretation of John viii. 56, 57, rather than upon external testimony,
and that the testimony (which itself may have been only the result of a subjective opinion) is dragged in only
for the sake of confirming a view already adopted. Such a fact as John’s own presence in Ephesus at a certain
period could hardly be subject to such uncertainty and to the influence of dogmatic prepossessions. It is signi-
ficant of Eusebius’ method that he omits entirely Irenæus’ statement as to the length of Christ’s ministry, with
which he did not agree (as shown by his account in Bk. I. chap. 10), while extracting from his statement the
single fact which he wishes here to establish. The falsity of the context he must have recognized, and yet, in his
respect for Irenæus, the great maintainer of sound doctrine, he nowhere refers to it. The information which
John is said, in this passage, to have conveyed to the “presbyters of Asia” is that Christ lived to old age. The
whole passage affords an instance of how much of error may be contained in what, to all appearances, should
be a very trustworthy tradition. Internal evidence must come to the support of external, and with all its alleged
uncertainty and subjectivity, must play a great part in the determination of the truth of history.
Narrative Concerning John the Apostle.
304
Narrative Concerning John the Apostle.