A few words may be added on the evidence of the
Vita as to the form and motive of early monachism. In the Life
of Antony, the stages are (1) ascetics living in the towns and
villages, not withdrawn from society (§§3, 4); (2) solitary
monasticism in the desert, away from human society; and, as the fame of
Antony increases, (3) the formation (§44) of clusters of cells
centering round some natural leader, the germ of the λαύρα (such as the community of
Tabennæ under Pachomius). Of organised monastic communities the
Vita tells us nothing. With regard to the motive of the
earliest monasticism, this has been variously sought in (1) the
development of the ascetic element present in Christianity from the
very first; (2) in the influence of the Alexandrian School, especially
Origen, who again is influenced by the spirit of revolt against the
body and detachment from the world which characterised neo-Platonism
(see Bornemann’s work mentioned above); (3) in the persecutions,
which drove Christians to the desert (Eus. H. E. vi. 42), which
some adopted as their home; (4) to the (not necessarily conscious)
imitation of analogous heathen institutions, especially the societies
of ἁγνεύοντες
which were gathered round or in the temples of Serapis (Weingarten,
R. E., X. 779–785. Revillout, p. 480 n, refers to Zoega,
p. 542, for the fact that Pachomius himself was a monk of Serapis
before his forced baptism by his Christian neighbours; and that after
it he continued his ascetic life with no external difference. (5) To
the desire to avoid civil obligations, already marked in the Rescript
of Valens (Cod. Th. xii. 1. 63, quidam ignauiæ sectatores
desertis civitatum muneribus, &c.). Of the above motives the
Vita gives no support to any but the first, which it directly
confirms, and perhaps indirectly to the second. The date of the
Vita depends mainly on the view to be taken of §82, where
see note 16.