science, that he has no reason to look on himself to be a saint, nay, even knows he is still in
a natural state, and therefore in the eye of his own impartial judgment is not such a one as
the sacrament by institution supposes the communicant to be? Moreover, Mr. Stoddard, in
describing visible saints, inserts into their character a serious profession of the true religion,
which he sometimes calls a profession of faith and repentance, morally sincere: and in his
Doctrine of Instituted Churches, (p. 19.) he lays down a remarkable position, in these words,
such a profession as being sincere makes a man a real saint, being morally sincere makes a
man a visible saint. Now according to this, it seems to me, the profession itself, whether
evangelically or morally sincere, is always of a uniform tenor; having one and the same thing
for the matter of it; and not respecting, in the different cases, a religion specifically different,
or a faith and repentance of a higher and a lower kind. But then it is quite beyond me to
comprehend, how a man who knows himself to be in a natural condition, can be so much
as morally sincere in his profession, while it is in its matter and tenor such a profession as
being (evangelically) sincere makes a man a real saint. For if he knows himself to be in a
natural condition, he then as certainly knows he hath not (in the principle or exercise) that
faith and repentance, which is the just matter of such a profession: and how therefore can
he be reasonably supposed, with any degree of moral sincerity, to make such a profession,
when for the matter of it, it is the very same profession he would make, if he knew himself
482
to be a real saint? Can a person in any sound gospel sense profess himself a saint or believing
penitent, and herein speak the truth with a common moral honesty, while yet he knows
himself to be destitute of all such characters in the sight of God and conscience, being still
in a natural condition, and under the dominion of unbelief and impenitence? For my own
part, I must confess this a difficulty in Mr. Stoddard’s scheme, that I am not capable of
solving. His favourite hypothesis, I think, must fall, if his position stands, and his concessions
be abode by; which serve clearly to determine the present question in the negative, agreeable
to the general sense of protestant churches and divines.
Quest. III. Whether it be not the general opinion, that persons admitted to the Lord’s table
ought to profess saving faith and repentance; meaning that faith and repentance, which are
the terms of the covenant of grace?
Answ. I believe, after what has been already offered, we need be at no loss to know the
mind of the generality respecting the subject of this inquiry. Were there occasion for it, I
could easily produce a cloud of witnesses, to evidence that the general opinion is on the af-
firmative side, in this question. Repeated searches have been made by diligent and impartial
inquirers, who though of varying judgment and practice in church-discipline, yet agree in
their reports: and from them I will give you the following attestations.
Mr. Lob (in his True Dissenter) tells us, It is the judgment of all the Nonconformists, that
nothing less than the profession of saving faith, credibly significant of the thing professed,
gives right to church-communion. And this he declares to be the rule of all protestants in
1885
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.