Chapter V.—By the Rule
of Antiquity, the Catholic Gospels are Found to Be True, Including the
Real St. Luke’s. Marcion’s Only a Mutilated Edition. The
Heretic’s Weakness and Inconsistency in Ignoring the Other
Gospels.
3585
On the whole, then, if that is evidently more true which
is earlier, if that is earlier which is from the very beginning, if
that is from the beginning which has the apostles for its authors, then
it will certainly be quite as evident, that that comes down from the
apos
tles, which has been kept
as a sacred deposit
3586
in the churches of
the apostles. Let us see what milk the Corinthians drank from Paul; to
what rule
of faith
the Galatians were brought for correction;
what the Philippians, the Thessalonians, the Ephesians read
by
it
; what utterance also the Romans give, so very near
3587
(to the apostles), to whom Peter and Paul
conjointly
3588
bequeathed the
gospel even sealed with their own blood. We have also
St.
John’s foster churches.
3589
For although
Marcion rejects his Apocalypse, the order
3590
of
the bishops (thereof), when traced up to their origin, will yet rest on
John as their author. In the same manner is recognised the excellent
source
3591
of the other
churches. I say, therefore, that in them (and not simply such of them
as were founded by apostles, but in all those which are united with
them in the fellowship of the mystery
of the gospel of
Christ
3592
) that Gospel of
Luke which we are defending with all our might has stood its ground
from its very first publication; whereas Marcion’s Gospel is not
known to most people, and to none whatever is it known without being at
the same time
3593
condemned. It too,
of course,
3594
has its churches,
but specially its own—as late as they are spurious; and should
you want to know their original,
3595
you will more
easily discover apostasy in it than apostolicity, with Marcion forsooth
as their founder, or some one of Marcion’s swarm.
3596
Even wasps make combs;
3597
so also these Marcionites make
churches. The same authority of the apostolic churches will
afford evidence
3598
to the other
Gospels also, which we possess equally through their means,
3599
and according to their usage—I mean
the Gospels of John and Matthew—whilst that which Mark published
may be affirmed to be Peter’s
3600
whose
interpreter Mark was. For even Luke’s form
3601
of the Gospel men usually ascribe to
Paul.
3602
And it may well seem
3603
that the works which disciples publish belong to their masters. Well,
then, Marcion ought to be called to a strict account
3604
concerning these (other Gospels) also, for
having omitted them, and insisted in preference
3605
on
Luke; as if they, too, had not had free course in the churches, as well
as Luke’s Gospel, from the beginning. Nay, it is even more
credible that they
3606
existed from the
very beginning; for, being the work of apostles, they were prior, and
coeval in origin with
3607
the churches
themselves. But how comes it to pass, if the apostles published
nothing, that their disciples were more forward in such a work; for
they could not have been disciples, without any instruction from their
masters? If, then, it be evident that these (Gospels) also were current
in the churches, why did not Marcion touch them—either to amend
them if they were adulterated, or to acknowledge them if they were
uncorrupt? For it is but natural
3608
that they who were perverting the gospel, should be more solicitous
about the perversion of those things whose authority they knew to be
more generally received. Even the false apostles (were so called) on
this very account, because they imitated the apostles by means of their
falsification. In
as
far, then, as he might have amended what
there was to amend, if found corrupt, in
so
far did he firmly
imply
3609
that all was free from corruption which he
did not think required amendment. In short,
3610
he
simply amended what he thought was corrupt; though, indeed, not even
this justly, because it was not really corrupt. For if the
(Gospels) of the apostles
3611
have come down to
us in their integrity, whilst Luke’s, which is received amongst
us,
3612
so far accords with their rule as to be on a
par with them in permanency of reception in the churches, it clearly
follows that Luke’s Gospel also has come down to us in like
integrity until the sacrilegious treatment of Marcion. In short, when
Marcion laid hands on it, it then became diverse and hostile to the
Gospels of the apostles. I will therefore advise his followers, that
they either change these Gospels, however late to do so, into a
conformity with their own, whereby they may seem to be in agreement
with the apostolic writings (for they are daily retouching their work,
as daily they are convicted by us); or else that they blush for their
master, who stands self-condemned
3613
either
way—when once
3614
he hands on the
truth of the gospel conscience smitten, or again
3615
subverts it by shameless tampering.
Such are the summary
arguments which we use, when we take up arms
3616
against heretics for the faith
3617
of the gospel,
maintaining both that order of periods, which rules that a late date is
the mark of forgers,
3618
and that authority
of churches
3619
which lends support
to the tradition of the apostles; because truth must needs precede the
forgery, and proceed straight from those by whom it has been handed
on.
3585
[On this whole chapter
and subject, consult Kaye, pp. 278–289.]
3586
Sacrosanctum.
Inviolate. Westcott,
On the Canon
, p. 384. Compare
De Præscript. Hæret
. c. 36,
supra
.
3587
De proximo.
Westcott renders this, “who are nearest to us.” See
in
loco
.
3588
et…et. [N.B. Not
Peter’s See, then.]
3589
Alumnas ecclesias. He
seems to allude to the seven churches of the Apocalypse.
3590
[Not the
Order
of bishops (as we now speak) but of their succession from
St. John. Kaye, p. 219.]
3591
Generositas.
3592
De societate
sacramenti. [i.e. Catholic Unity.]
3593
Eadem.
3594
Plane.
3595
Censum.
3596
Examine.
3597
Favos. See
Pliny,
Nat. Hist
. xi. 21.
3598
Patrocinabitur. [Jones
on the Canon, Vol. I. p. 66.]
3599
Proinde per illas.
3600
See Hieronymus,
Catal. Scriptt. Eccles
. c. 8.
3601
Digestum.
3602
See above, chap. 2, p.
347.
3603
Capit videri.
3604
Flagitandus.
3605
Potius institerit.
3606
The Gospels of the
apostles John and Matthew, and perhaps Mark’s also, as being St.
Peter’s.
3607
Dedicata cum.
3608
Competit.
3609
Confirmavit.
3610
Denique.
3611
Apostolica, i.e.,
evangelia.
3612
That is, the canonical
Gospel of St. Luke, as distinct from Marcion’s corruption of it.
[N.B. “Us” = Catholics.]
3613
Traducto.
3614
Nunc—nunc.
3615
Nunc—nunc.
3616
Expedimur.
3617
Fide, integrity.
3618
Posteritati
falsariorum præscribentem.
3619
[Mark the authority of
churches. He uses the plural—
quod ab omnibus
.]