Whatever may be the truth of Dionysius’ report as to
Peter’s martyrdom at Rome, he is almost certainly in error in
speaking as he does of Peter’s work in Corinth. It is difficult,
to be sure, to dispose of so direct and early a tradition, but it is
still more difficult to accept it. The statement that Paul and Peter
together planted the Corinthian church is certainly an error, as we
know that it was Paul’s own church, founded by him alone. The
so-called Cephas party, mentioned in 1 Cor. i., is perhaps
easiest explained by the previous presence and activity of Peter in
Corinth, but this is by no means necessary, and the absence of any
reference to the fact in the two epistles of Paul renders it almost
absolutely impossible. It is barely possible, though by no means
probable, that Peter visited Corinth on his way to Rome (assuming the
Roman journey) and that thus, although the church had already been
founded many years, he became connected in tradition with its early
days, and finally with its origination. But it is more probable that
the tradition is wholly in error and arose, as Neander suggests, partly
from the mention of Peter in 1 Cor. i., partly from the
natural desire to ascribe the origin of this great apostolic church to
the two leading apostles, to whom in like manner the founding of the
Roman church was ascribed. It is significant that this tradition is
recorded only by a Corinthian, who of course had every inducement to
accept such a report, and to repeat it in comparing his own church with
the central church of Christendom. We find no mention of the tradition
in later writers, so far as I am aware.