\par\par\pard (\cf13\b And it was the third hour, and they crucified him.)
\par\par (\cf13\i [And it was the third hour, and they crucified him.]) But John saith, (\cf11\ul John 19:14), (\i And it was the preparation of the Passover, and about the sixth hour); namely, when Pilate delivered him to be crucified. From the former clause, (\i it was the preparation of the Passover); hath sprung that opinion, of which we have said something before concerning the transferring of the eating of the lamb this year to the fifteenth day. For they think by (\i the preparation of the Passover) is to be understood the preparation of the lamb, or for the eating of the lamb. For which interpretation they think that makes, which is said by the same John, (\cf11\ul John 18:28), "They would not go into the judgment-hall, lest they should be defiled, but that they might eat the Passover." And hence it is confidently concluded by them, that however Christ ate his lamb the day before, yet the Jews were to eat theirs this very day.
\par\par We will discourse first of the (\i day); as it here occurs under the name of (\i the preparation of the Passover); and then of the (\i hour); --
\par\par I. Every Israelite was bound, within that seven day's solemnity, after the lamb was eaten, to these two things: 1. To appear before the Lord in the court, and that with a sacrifice. 2. To solemn joy and mirth, and that also with sacrifices. The former was called by the Jews (\i Appearance). The latter (\i (\cf9\b Chagigah), the festival).
\par\par "(\i All are bound to appear); except deaf-and-dumb, fools, young children," etc. And a little after; "The school of (\cf9\b Shammai) saith, (\i Let the Appearance be with two silver pieces of money, and the (\cf9\b Chagigah) be with a 'meah' of silver). The school of (\cf9\b Hillel) saith, Let the (\i Appearance) be with a (\cf9\b meah) of silver, and the (\cf9\b Chagigah) with two pieces of silver." The Gloss writes thus; "All are bound to make their appearance from that precept, 'All thy males shall appear,' etc. (\cf11\ul Exodus 23:17); and it is necessary that they appear in the court in the feast. He that appears when he placeth himself in the court, let him bring a burnt offering, which is by no means to be of less price than two pieces of silver, that is, of two (\cf9\b meahs) of silver. They are bound also to the peace offerings of the (\cf9\b Chagigah) by that law, (\i Ye shall keep it a feast to the LORD);" (\cf11\ul Exodus 12:14). Rambam upon the place thus; "The Lord saith, 'Let them not appear before me empty,' (\cf11\ul Deuteronomy 16:16).
That is, Let him bring (\i an oblation of a burnt sacrifice) in his hand when he goes up to the feast. And those burnt sacrifices are called (\i burnt-sacrifices of appearance); and also (\i appearance); without the addition of the word (\i burnt sacrifice). And the (\cf9\b Chagigah); From thence, because the Lord saith, 'Ye shall keep it a feast to the Lord,' it means this, (\i That a man bring peace offerings); and these peace offerings are called (\cf9\b Chagigah)."
\par\par II. Of these two, namely, the (\i appearance) and the (\cf9\b Chagigah); the (\cf9\b Chagigah) was the greater and more famous. For
\par\par First, certain persons were obliged to the (\cf9\b Chagigah); who were not obliged to the (\i appearance); "He that indeed is not deaf, but yet is dumb, is not obliged to (\i appearance); but yet he is obliged (\i to rejoice)." It is true some of the Gemarists distinguish between (\cf9\b Chagigah) and (\i rejoicing). But one Glosser upon the place alleged (\i that which he saith of 'rejoicing,' obtains also of the (\cf9\b 'Chagigah.')) And another saith, "He is bound (\i to rejoicing); namely, to rejoice in the feast; as it is written, 'And thou shalt rejoice in thy feast.' And they say elsewhere, that that rejoicing is over the peace-offerings, namely, in eating flesh."
\par\par Secondly, (\i appearance) was not tied so strictly to the first day, but the (\cf9\b Chagigah) was tied to it. "(\i Burnt sacrifices by vow, and free will offerings are offered on the common days of the feast, they are not offered on a feast day: but the burnt sacrifices of appearance may be offered also on a feast day); and when they are offered, let them not be offered but (\i out of common cattle: but the peace offerings of rejoicing) also out of the tithes (\i the (\cf9\b 'Chagigah') of the first feast day of the Passover). The school of (\cf9\b Shammai) saith, Let it be of (\i common cattle); the school of (\cf9\b Hillel) saith, Let it be of the tithes. What is it that it teaches of (\i the (\cf9\b Chagigah) of the first feast day of the Passover)? Rabh Ishai saith, (\i the (\cf9\b 'Chagigah') of the fifteenth day is so: the (\cf9\b 'Chagigah') of the fourteenth, not)." The Gloss is; "The burnt offerings of appearance were not offered the first day of the feast, although they were due to the feast, because compensation might be made by them the day following."
\par\par "The (\cf9\b 'Chagigah') of the first feast day was without doubt due; although it had flesh enough otherways." For, as it is said a little before, "They offered peace offerings on that feast day (\i because they had need of them for private food) ": and although there was food enough, yet the (\cf9\b Chagigah) was to be offered as the due of the day.
\par\par "The (\cf9\b Chagigah) of the fourteenth day was this, (\i when any company was numerous); they joined the (\cf9\b Chagigah) also with the paschal lamb, that they might eat the passover, even till they were filled. But now the (\cf9\b Chagigah) of that first day was not but of common cattle: but the (\cf9\b Chagigah) of the fourteenth day might also be of the tithes."
\par\par It was a greater matter to offer of common cattle (or (\cf9\b cholin)) than of the tithes of the first-born, for they were owing to the Lord by right: but to offer the (\cf9\b cholin) was the part of further devotion and free will.
\par\par That therefore which John saith, that "the Jews would not go into the judgment hall lest they should be polluted, but that they might eat the passover," is to be understood of that (\cf9\b Chagigah) of the fifteenth day, not of the paschal lamb: for that also is called the passover, (\cf11\ul Deuteronomy 16:2); "Thou shalt sacrifice the (\i passover) to the Lord of thy flocks and of thy herds." (\i Of thy flocks); this indeed, by virtue of that precept, (\cf11\ul Exodus 12:3); but what have we to do with (\i herds)? "'Of thy herds,' saith R. Solomon, for the (\cf9\b Chagigah)." And Aben Ezra saith, "'Of thy flocks,' according to the duty of the passover; 'of thy herds,' for the peace offerings," and produceth that, (\cf11\ul 2 Chronicles 30:24); (\cf11\ul 2 Chronicles 35:8). The Targum of Jonathan writes; "Ye shall kill the passover before the Lord your God, between the eves, and your sheep and oxen on the morrow, in that very day, in joy of the feast."
\par\par In one Glosser mention is made of (\i the less passover); by which if he understands not the passover of the second month, which is very usually called by them (\i the second passover); or the passover of the second month, instruct me what he means by it. However this matter is clear in Moses, that oxen, or the sacrifices offered after the lamb eaten, are called the 'passover,' as well as the lamb itself.
\par\par And no wonder, when the lamb was the very least part of the joy, and there were seven feast-days after he was eaten: and when the lamb was a thing rubbing up the remembrance of affliction, rather than denoting gladness and making merry. For the unleavened bread was marked out by the holy Scripture under that very notion, and so also the bitter herbs, which were things that belonged to the lamb. But how much of the solemnity of the feast is attributed to the (\cf9\b Chagigah); and the other sacrifices after that, it would be too much to mention, since it occurs everywhere.
\par\par Hear the author of the (\cf9\b Aruch) concerning the (\cf9\b Chagigah) of Pentecost: "The word (\i chag) denotes dancing, and clapping hands for joy. In the Syriac language it is (\cf9\b chigah); and from this root it is, because they eat, and drink, and dance (\cf15\i [or make holiday]). And the sacrifice of the (\cf9\b Chagigah); which they were bound to bring on a feast day, is that concerning which the Scripture saith, (\i and thou shalt make (\cf9\b chag), a solemnity of weeks) to the Lord thy God, a free will offering of thy hand,' " etc. (\cf11\ul Deuteronomy 16:10).
\par\par And now tell me whence received that feast its denomination, that it should be called (\i the feast) of weeks? Not from the offering of the loaves of first fruits, but from the (\cf9\b Chagigah); and the feasting on the (\cf9\b Chagigah). The same is to be said of the feast of the Passover. So that John said nothing strange to the ears of the Jews, when he said, "They went not into the judgment hall lest they might be polluted, but that they might eat the passover"; pointing with his finger to the (\cf9\b Chagigah); and not to the lamb, eaten indeed the day before.
\par\par The word (\i passover) might sound to the same sense in those words of his also, "It was the preparation of the passover, and about the sixth hour." It was the preparation to the (\cf9\b Chagigah); and not to the lamb. But I suspect something more may be understood; namely, that on that day both food was prepared, and the mind too for the mirth of the whole feast. So that the passover denotes (\i the feast); not this or that particular appendage to the feast. The burnt sacrifices which were offered in the (\i appearance, they all became God's); as the masters say truly; and he who offered them carried not back the least part of them with him. But the sacrifices of the (\cf9\b Chagigah); whether they were oxen or sheep, the greatest part of them returned to them that offered them; and with them they and their friends made solemn and joyful feastings while they tarried at Jerusalem. So that the oblation of these on the first day of the feast was (\i the preparation of the passover); and (\i the preparation of Pentecost); and (\i the preparation of the feast of Tabernacles); that is, the day and manner of preparing food for the following mirth of the feast.
In the same sense was (\i the preparation of the sabbath); namely, (\i the preparation) of food and things necessary to the sabbath. Of which we shall speak at (\cf11\ul Mark 15:42).
\par\par Having thus despatched these things, let us now come to the (\i hour) itself. "It was the preparation of the passover (saith John), and about the (\i sixth) hour," when Pilate delivered Christ to be crucified. "And it was the (\i third) hour (saith Mark), and they crucified him."
\par\par It is disputed by the Gemarists, how far the evidences of two men may agree and consent, whereof one saith, 'This I saw done in that hour'; and the other saith, 'I saw it done another hour.' "One saith, the second hour; another, the third: (\i their testimony consists together). One saith the third hour, another the fifth; (\i their testimony is vain); as R. Meir saith. But saith R. Judah, their testimony consists together. But if one saith, the fifth hour, another, the seventh hour, their testimony is vain; because in the fifth hour the sun is in the east part of heaven; in the seventh, in the west part." They dispute largely concerning this matter in the place alleged, and concerning evidences differing in words; nevertheless, as to the thing itself, they conclude that both may be true, because witnesses may be deceived in the computation of hours: which to conclude concerning the evangelists, were impious and blasphemous.
But there is one supposes the copiers were deceived in their transcription, and would have the computation of John corrected into (\i and it was about the third hour); too boldly, and indeed without any reason, for it is neither credible nor possible indeed, that those things which went before our Saviour's crucifixion should be done (to use the words of the Talmudists) (\i in the three first hours of the day). The harmony therefore of the evangelists is to be fetched elsewhere.
\par\par I. Let us repeat that out of (\cf9\b Maimonides); "The great (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) sat from the morning daily sacrifice, until the afternoon daily sacrifice." But now when the morning daily sacrifice was at the third hour, the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) sat not before that hour. Take heed, therefore, thou that wouldest have the words of John, "and it was about the (\i sixth) hour," to be changed into, "and it was about the (\i third) hour," lest thou becomest guilty of a great solecism. For Pilate could not deliver Christ to be crucified about the third hour, when the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) sat not before the third hour, and Christ was not yet delivered to Pilate.
\par\par But you will say, the words of Mark do obscure these things much more. For if the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) that delivered up Christ met not together before the third hour, one can no way say that they crucified him the third hour.
\par\par We do here propound two things for the explanation of this matter.
\par\par Let the first be taken from the (\i day) itself, and from the (\i hour) itself. That day was "the preparation of the passover," a day of high solemnity, and when it behoved the priests and the other fathers of the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) to be present at the third hour in the Temple, and to offer their Chagigahs that were preparative to the whole seven days' festivity: but they employed themselves in another thing, namely this. You may observe that he saith not, "it was the third hour (\i when) "; but "it was the third hour, (\i and) they crucified him." That is, when the third hour now was, and was passed, yet they omitted not to prosecute his crucifixion, when indeed, according to the manner of the feast and the obligation of religion, they ought to have been employed otherwise. I indeed should rather sit down satisfied with this interpretation, than accuse the holy text as depraved, or to deprave it more with my amendment. But,
\par\par Secondly, there is another sense also not to be despised, if our judgment is any thing, which we fetch from a custom usual in the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim), but from which they now swerved. They are treating concerning a guilty person condemned to hanging, with whom they deal in this process: (\i they tarry until sunset approach, and then they finish his judgment and put him to death). Note that: 'They finish not his judgment until sunset draw near.' If you ask the reason, a more general one may be given which respected all persons condemned to die, and a more special one which respected him which was to be hanged.
\par\par I. There was that which is called by the Talmudists (\i the affliction of judgment); by which phrase they understand not judgment that is not just, but when he that is condemned, after judgment passed, is not presently put to death. "(\i If you finish his judgment on the sabbath) (\cf15\i [mark that]), (\i and put him to death on the first day of the week, you afflict his judgment)." Where the Gloss is, "As long as his judgment is not finished, it is not the affliction of judgment, because he expects every hour to be absolved: but when judgment is ended, he expects death," etc. Therefore they delayed but little between the finishing of judgment and execution.
\par\par II. As to those that were to be hanged, "(\i they delayed the finishing his judgment); and they hanged him not in the morning, lest they might grow slack about his burial, and might fall into forgetfulness," and might sin against the law, (\cf11\ul Deuteronomy 21:23); "but near sunset, that they might presently bury him." So the Gloss. They put him to death not sooner, for this reason; they finished not his judgment sooner for the reason above said.
\par\par And now let us resume the words of Mark, "And it was the third hour, and they crucified him." The (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) used not to finish the judgment of hanging until they were now ready to rise up and depart from the council and bench after the (\cf9\b Mincha), the day now inclining towards sunset: but these men finished the judgment of Jesus, and hastened him to the cross, when they first came into the court at the third hour, at the time of the daily sacrifice, which was very unusual, and different from the custom.
\par\par