they make out that these deaths are justly the occasion of odium against us, and of glory to
them. They take no blame to themselves for the harm which they do to us, and they lay upon
us the blame of the harm which they bring upon themselves. They live as robbers, they die
as Circumcelliones, they are honoured as martyrs! Nay, I do injustice to robbers in this
comparison; for we have never heard of robbers destroying the eyesight of those whom they
have plundered: they indeed take away those whom they kill from the light, but they do not
take away the light from those whom they leave in life.
9. On the other hand, if at any time we get men of your party into our power, we keep
them unharmed, showing great love towards them; and we tell them everything by which
the error which has severed brother from brother is refuted. We do as the Lord Himself
commanded us, in the words of the prophet Isaiah: “Hear the word of the Lord, ye that
tremble at His word; say, Ye are our brethren, to those who hate you, and who cast you out,
that the name of the Lord may be glorified, and that He may appear to them with joy; but
let them be put to shame.”2112 And thus some of them we persuade, through their consid-
ering the evidences of the truth and the beauty of peace, not to be baptized anew for this
sign of allegiance to our king they have already received (though they were as deserters),
but to accept that faith, and love of the Holy Spirit, and union to the body of Christ, which
formerly they had not. For it is written, “Purifying their hearts by faith;”2113 and again,
“Charity covereth a multitude of sins.”2114 If, however, either through too great obduracy,
or through shame making them unable to bear the taunts of those with whom they were
accustomed to join so frequently in falsely reproaching us and contriving evil against us, or
perhaps more through fear lest they should come to share along with us such injuries as
they were formerly wont to inflict on us,—if, I say, from any of these causes, they refuse to
be reconciled to the unity of Christ, they are allowed to depart, as they were detained, without
suffering any harm. We also exhort our laity as far as we can to detain them without doing
them any harm, and bring them to us for admonition and instruction. Some of them obey
us and do this, if it is in their power: others deal with them as they would with robbers, be-
cause they actually suffer from them such things as robbers are wont to do. Some of them
strike their assailants in protecting their own bodies from their blows: while others apprehend
them and bring them to the magistrates; and though we intercede on their behalf, they do
not let them off, because they are very much afraid of their savage outrages. Yet all the while,
these men, though persisting in the practices of robbers, claim to be honoured as martyrs
when they receive the due reward of their deeds!
2112 Isa. lxvi. 5, as given by Augustin.
2113 Acts xv. 9.
2114 1 Pet. iv. 8.
827
To Januarius