375
ciency; and so he returns to the necessity for toleration within the net, as Judas was forborne
in the apostolic company. The epilogue pictures the personified Church expostulating with
the Donatists for quarreling with their Mother, and presents a loose summary of the previous
arguments.
It is doubtful whether, even in the fashion of the times, so lengthy a poem could become
a street theme, or find many repeaters in the markets and inns of Hippo or Carthage, although
the refrain for peace and truthful judgment might catch the ear of the more zealous. [Cp.
Retractt. I. xx.].
The Bishop of Carthage, Donatus the Great, the sphinx of Donatism, had written a book
to vindicate the claim of his church to the only Christian baptism. The work obtained
considerable currency, and maintained its authority, even in Augustin’s day, so he answered
it during the year 393, most probably, in a treatise of one book now no longer extant, but
which has been given the title: "Contra Epistolam Donati hæretici," The Retractations (I.
xxi.) correct some points which had been held in this work. (1). According to the Ambrosian
view, Augustin here identified Peter with the rock, on which the Church was to be built;
but afterwards he regarded that rock as Christ, who was the subject of the Petrine confession;
on Christ was the Church to be built, and to the Church as thus reared, were given the keys.
(2). The Donatus present at the Roman Synod, he had spoken of as the bishop of Carthage,
the author of the book, which error is corrected in the Retractations. (3). He had also charged
the writer with falsifying a favorite passage of their side, Ecclus. xxxiv. 30, but afterwards
found that some codices read according to the Donatist quotation, and apologizes for his
assertions.
Doubtless many of the sermons preached during his presbyterate had reference to the
schism, but the chronology of these is too uncertain to allow of any definite arrangement.
We pass to the period of his co-bishopric with the aged Valerius, which dates from 395
A.D.
Evodius, a brother connected with the Church at Hippo Regius, had a chance meeting
with Proculeianus, bishop of the Donatist body in that diocese. The two fell into a discussion
of their mutual differences. Evodius spoke in rather a lofty and censorious way, after the
fashion of his side, and wounded the feelings of the older disputant, for the Donatists, like
all kindred bodies, cultivated an undue sensitiveness and were altogether too ready to take
offense. Proculeianus, however, expressed a perfect readiness to have a friendly debate with
Augustin in the presence of competent men. In view of this suggestion, and in the absence
of Valerius, Augustin, always anxious to improve such an opening, addressed a letter to
Proculeianus (c. 396), with courteous recognition, and no such sharp denial of the episcopal
function as in the case of Maximin. He apologizes for the severe language of his friend, and
in every way avoids any expression which might cause the tendrils again to be drawn in.
The methods suggested for discussion show the anxiety of Augustin to beat out the fire of
651
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.