Book XXVIII.
Faustus recurs to the genealogy and insists upon examining it as regards its consistency
with itself. Augustin takes his stand on Scripture authority and maintains that Matthew’s
statements as to the birth of Christ must be accepted as final.
1. Faustus said: Christ, you say, could not have died, had He not been born. I reply,
If He was born, He cannot have been God; or if He could both be God and be born, why
could He not both be born and die? Plainly, arguments and necessary consequences are
not applicable to those matters, where the question is of the account to be given of Jesus.
The answer must be obtained from His own statements, or from the statements of His
apostles regarding Him. The genealogy must be examined as regards its consistency with
325
itself, instead of arguing from the supposition of Christ’s death to the fact of His birth; for
He might have suffered without having been born, or He might have been born, and yet
never have suffered; for you yourselves acknowledge that with God nothing is impossible,
which is inconsistent with the denial that Christ could have suffered without having been
born.
2. Augustin replied: You are always answering arguments which no one uses, instead
of our real arguments, which you cannot answer. No one says that Christ could not die if
He had not been born; for Adam died though he had not been born. What we say is, Christ
was born, because this is said not by this or that heretic, but in the holy Gospel; and He died,
for this too is written, not in some heretical production, but in the holy Gospel. You set
aside argument on the question of the true account to be given of Jesus, and refer to what
He says of Himself, and what His apostles say of Him; and yet, when I begin to quote the
Gospel of His apostle Matthew, where we have the whole narrative of Christ’s birth, you
forthwith deny that Matthew wrote the narrative, though this is affirmed by the continuous
testimony of the whole Church, from the days of apostolic presidency to the bishops of our
own time. What authority will you quote against this? Perhaps some book of Manichæus,
where it is denied that Jesus was born of a virgin. As, then, I believe your book to be the
production of Manichæus, since it has been kept and handed down among the disciples of
Manichæus, from the time when he lived to the present time, by a regular succession of
your presidents, so I ask you to believe the book which I quote to have been written by
Matthew, since it has been handed down from the days of Matthew in the Church, without
any break in the connection between that time and the present. The question then is,
whether we are to believe the statements of an apostle who was in the company of Christ
while He was on earth, or of a man away in Persia, born long after Christ. But perhaps you
will quote some other book bearing the name of an apostle known to have been chosen by
Christ; and you will find there that Christ was not born of Mary. Since, then, one of the
books must be false, the question in this case is, whether we are to yield our belief to a book
acknowledged and approved as handed down from the beginning in the Church founded
Faustus recurs to the genealogy and insists upon examining it as regards its consistency with itself. Augustin takes his stand on Scripture authority and maintains that Matthew’s statements as to the birth of Christ must be accepted as final.
554
Faustus recurs to the genealogy and insists upon examining it as regards…