TO PAMMACHIUS AGAINST JOHN OF JERUSALEM. 431
the day stirred you up, you made a discourse
in his hearing, and in that of the whole
Church, concerning the faith and all the doc- trines of the Church. After this we cannot
but wonder at the weakness of Demosthenes ;
for we are told that he spent a long time in
elaborating his splendid oration against
^Eschines. We are quite mistaken in looking
up to Tully ; for his merit, according to
Cornelius Nepos, who was present, was noth-
ing but this, that he delivered his famous
defence of the seditious tribune Cornelius,
almost word for word as it was published.
Behold a Lysias * and a Gracchus raised up for us ! or, to name one of more modern days, a
Quintus Aterius, * the man who had all his powers at hand like a stock of ready money, so that he needed some one to tell him when to
stop, and of whom Caesar Augustus said very
well, " Our friend Quintus must have the
break put on." 13. Is there any man in his right senses
who would declare that in a single sermon
he had discussed the faith and all 'he doc-
trines of the Church ? Pray show me what that lesson is which is so seasoned with the
whole savour of Scripture that its occurrence
in the service induced you to enter the arena
and put your wit to the hazard. And if you
had not been overwhelmed by the torrent of
your eloquence, you might have been con-
vinced that it was impossible for you to speak
upon the whole circle of doctrines without
any deliberation. But how stands the case ?
You promise one thing and present another.
Our custom is, for the space of forty days, to
deliver public lectures to those who are to be
baptized on the doctrine of the Holy and
Adorable Trinity. If the lesson for the day
stimulated you to discuss all doctrines in a
single hour, what necessity was there to repeat
the instruction of the previous forty days ?
But if you meant to recapitulate what you had
been saying during the whole of Lent, how
could one lesson on a certain day " stir you
up " to speak of all these doctrines ? But even here his language is ambiguous ; for pos-
sibly he took occasion, from the particular
lesson, to go over summarily what he was
accustomed to deliver in church to the candi-
dates for baptism during the forty days of
Lent. For it is eloquence all the same,
whether few things are said in many words,
or many things in few words. There is
another permissible meaning, that, as soon as
the one lesson gave him the spur, he was fired
with such oratorical zeal that for forty days
he never ceased speaking. But, then, even
1 A celebrated orator of Athens, many of whose orations are ex- tant. B. 458, d. 378 B.C.
1 This story is from the 4th Declamation of Seneca.
the easy-going old man, who was hanging upon
his lips, and longing to know what he had
never heard before, must have almost fallen
from his seat asleep. However, we must
put up with it ; perhaps this, also, is a case
of the simplicity which we know to be his manner.
14. Let us quote the rest, in which, after
the labyrinths of his perplexing discussion,
he expresses himself by no means ambigu-
ously but openly, and thus concludes his
wonderful homilies : " When we had thus
spoken in his presence, and when out of the
extreme honour which we paid him we invited
him to speak after us, he praised our preach-
ing, and said that he marvelled at it, and
declared to all that it was the Catholic faith."
The extreme honour you paid him is evi-
denced by the extreme insults offered to him,
when through the archdeacon you bade him
be silent, and loudly proclaimed that it was the
love of praise which made him linger among
the crowd. The present is the key to the
past. For three whole years from that time
he has brooded in silence ' over the wrongs he suffered, and, spurning all personal strife, has
only asked for a more correct expression of
your faith. You, with your endless resources,
and making a profit out of the religion of the
whole world, have been sending those very
dignified envoys of yours hither and thither,
and have been trying to awake the old man
out of his sleep that he might answer you.
And in truth it was right that as you had con-
ferred such signal honour upon him he should
praise your utterances, particularly such as
were ex tempore. But as men have a way of
sometimes praising what they do not approve,
and of nourishing another's folly by meaning- less commendation, he not only praised your
utterances, but praised and marvelled at them
as well ; and what is more, to magnify the
marvel, he declared to the whole people that
they were in harmony with the Catholic faith.
Whether he really said all this, we ourselves
are witnesses. The fact is, he came to us
half dead with dismay at your words, and
saying that he had been too precipitate in
communicating with you. And further, when
he was much entreated by the whole monas-
tery to return to you from Bethlehem, and was unable to resist the entreaties of so
many, he did indeed return in the evening,
but only to escape again at midnight. His
letters to the pope Siricius prove the same
thing, and if you read them you will see
clearly in what sense he marvelled at your
utterances and acknowledged them Catholic.
But we are threshing chaff, and have spent
1 Literally "devours his wrongs."