SECT. V.
Showing that Mr. Williams, in supposing that unsanctified men may profess such things,
as he allows must be professed, and yet speak true, is inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard, and
with himself.
Mr. W. denies, that in order to men being admitted to sacraments, they need make any
peculiar profession, distinguished from what an unregenerate man may make, (p. 44. c. p.
50. e. 6. c. d. e. 9. c. 10. c. e. 45. e. 46. a. and 53. e.) or that they need to profess any thing but
what an unregenerate man may say, and speak true. (p. 47. c.) And that they need make no
profession but what is compatible with an unregenerate state, (p. 8. d. e.) And yet the reader
has seen what things he says all must profess in order to come to sacraments. One thing he
says they must profess, is a real conviction of the heart, of the divine truth of God’s word;
that they do sincerely and with all their hearts believe the gospel. And these things, he says,
are agreeable to the opinion of Mr. Stoddard, and the doctrine he taught. (p. 32. b. c. and p.
36. a.) Let us compare these things with the doctrine Mr. S. taught. Mr. S. taught, that nat-
ural men do not believe the gospel, (Benef. of the Gosp. p. 89. b.) that they do not properly
believe the word of God. (Guide to Christ, p. 26. d.) That they do not believe the testimony
of God, do not lay weight on the word of God; that they do not believe the report of the
gospel. (Safety of Ap. Edit. 2. p. 229. c. e.) that they do not receive God’s testimony, nor lay
weight on it. (Ibid. p. 99.) That there is no man, how great soever his profession, how large
soever his knowledge, that continues in a natural condition, who thoroughly believes that
truth; i.e. that men may be saved by Christ’s righteousness. (Ibid. p. 4. d. and p. 5. d. e.) That
common illumination does not convince men of the truth of the gospel. (Benef. of the Gosp.
p. 148, 149.) How then could it be the doctrine Mr. S. taught, that natural men may really
and with all their hearts believe and be convinced of the truth of the gospel?
And Mr. W. himself, in his sermons on Christ a King and Witness, (p. 114, 115.) says,
“man since the fall is naturally ignorant of divine truth, and an enemy to it, and full or pre-
judices against the truth:” and further, (ibid. p. 114.) “The renewing of the Holy Ghost makes
an universal change of the heart and life.—He knows the doctrine contained in the Bible in
a new manner.—Before, he had a view of the truth as a doubtful uncertain thing; he received
it as a thing which was probably true;—and perhaps for the most part it appeared something
likely to answer the end proposed.—But now the gospel appears to him divinely true and
real,“ &c. But how do these things consist with men being, before conversion, sincerely and
with all their hearts convinced of the divine truth of the gospel? Can that be, and yet men
view it as a doubtful uncertain thing, as not yet appearing to them divinely true and real?
Again, Mr. W. supposes, that some unsanctified men may speak true, and profess a
hearty consent to the terms of the covenant of grace, a compliance with the call of the gospel,
submission to the proposals of it, satisfaction with that device for our salvation that is revealed
in the gospel, and with the offer which God makes of himself to be our God in Christ Jesus,
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.
1934
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.