because he is mutilated. Things such as that are the misfortunes of nature; they escape blame
from those who can reflect. This strength of vituperation, then, is infirmity in reasoning; it
is an affliction of a soul whose powers of sound argument are marred. No word from me,
then, about his invectives. But as to that syllogism, with its stout irrefragable folds, in whose
conclusion, to effect his darling object, he arrives at this accusation against us, I will write
it out in its own precise words. “We will allow him to say that the Son exists by participation
in the self-existent1217; but (instead of this), he has unconsciously affirmed that the God
over all comes from absolute nonentity. For if the idea of the absence of everything amounts
to that of absolute nonentity1218, and the transposition of equivalents is perfectly legitimate,
then the man who says that God comes from nothing says that He comes from nonentity.”
To which of these statements shall we first direct our attention? Shall we criticize his opinion
about the Son “existing by participation” in the Deity, and his bespattering those who will
not acquiesce in it with the foulness of his tongue; or shall we examine the sophism so frigidly
constructed from the stuff of dreams? However, every one who possesses a spark of practical
sagacity is not unaware that it is only poets and moulders of mythology who father sons “by
participation” upon the Divine Being. Those, that is, who string together the myths in their
poems, fabricate a Dionysus, or a Hercules, or a Minos, and such-like, out of the combination
of the superhuman with human bodies; and they exalt such personages above the rest of
mankind, representing them as of greater estimation because of their participation in a su-
perior nature. Therefore, with regard to this opinion of his, carrying as it does within itself
the evidence of its own folly and profanity, it is best to be silent; and to repeat instead that
irrefragable syllogism of his, in order that every poor ignoramus on our side may understand
what and how many are the advantages which those who are not trained in his technical
methods are deprived of. He says, “If the idea of the absence of everything amounts to that
of absolute nonentity, and the transposition of equivalents is perfectly legitimate, then the
man who says that God comes from nothing, says that He comes from nonentity.” He
brandishes over us this Aristotelian weapon, but who has yet conceded to him, that to say
that any one has no father amounts to saying that he has been generated from absolute
nonentity? He who enumerates those persons whose line is recorded in Scripture is plainly
thinking of a father preceding each person mentioned. For what relation is Heli to Joseph?
What relation is Matthat to Heli? And what relation is Adam to Seth? Is it not plain to a
mere child that this catalogue of names is a list of fathers? For if Seth is the son of Adam,
Adam must be the father of one thus born from him; and so tell me, who is the father of the
Deity Who is over all? Come, answer this question, open your lips and speak, exert all your
skill in expression to meet such an inquiry. Can you discover any expression that will elude
1217 τοῦ ὄντος
1218 τὸ μηδὲν τῷ πάντη μὴ ὄντι ταὐτὸν.
585
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.