not of him that willeth] These words contain the conclusion of the Apostles answere, therefore God is not unjust in chusing and saving of his free goodnesse such as it pleaseth him; as he also answered Moses when he prayed for all the people. By will, he meaneth here, the thoughts and desires of the heart; by running, our earnest endeavours, and good works, and commendable course of life; to neither of which yet hee ascribeth the praise, but onely to the mercy of God. Upon this verse S. Austine acutely observes in his Enchiridion, against the Pelagians, that when the Apostle saith, It is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth; the meaning cannot be, that it is not wholly of him that willeth, or of him that runneth, but partly of him that willeth, and partly of him that runneth, and partly of God that hath mercy: for according to that exposition, the Apostle might have said, It is not of him that hath mercy, but of him that willeth or runneth; because, according to their Pelagian tenet, it is not wholly of God that hath mercy, but partly of him that willeth, and of him that runneth. But if no man dare say that it is not of God that hath mercy, for that were in direct terms to contradict the Apostle; it remaineth therefore that this must be the sense, That it is not at all of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but wholly of God, who hath mercy, qui voluntatem praeparat adjuvandam, & adjuvat praeparatam.