AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I. 447
that if any one says Paulinianus was conse-
crated presbyter by Epiphanius, he is to be forbidden to enter the Church. Ever since
that time to this day we can only look from
without on the cave of the Saviour, and,
while heretics enter, we stand afar off and sigh.
43. Are we schismatics ? Is not he the
schismatic who refuses a habitation to the
living, a grave to the dead, and demands the exile of his brethren ? Who was it that
set at our throats, with special fury, that wild
beast who constantly menaced the throats of
the whole world ? l Who is it that permits the rain to beat upon the bones of the saints,
and their harmless ashes, up to the present
hour ? These are the endearments with which
the good shepherd invites us to reconciliation,
and at the same time accuses us of setting up
an authority of our own — us who are united in communion and charity with all the bishops,
so long, at least, as they are orthodox. Do
you yourself constitute the Church, and is
whosoever offends you shut out from Christ ?
If we defend our own authority — prove that
we have a bishop in your diocese. The
reason that we have not had communion with-
you is the question of faith ; answer our ques- tions, and it will become one 6f order.
44. "They," you go on, "also take advantage of other letters which they say Epiphaniuswrote
to them. But he, too, shall give account for all
his doings before the judgment seat of Christ,
where great and small shall be judged without
respect of persons. Still, how can they rely
on his letter which he wrote only because we
took him to task on the matter of the unlaw-
ful ordination of Paulinianus and his associ-
ates ; as in the opening of that very letter he
intimates?" What, I ask, is the meaning of this blindness ? how is it that he is immersed,
as the saying goes, in Cimmerian darkness ?
He says that we make a pretext, and that we
have no letters from Epiphanius against him,
1 The allusion is believed to be to the Prefect Rufinus, who was
at the head of the government under the young Arcadius, and
whose intrigues with Alaric with a view to obtain the empire for
himself led to his death in the end of 395. — Comp. Letter LXXXII. 10.
and he immediately adds, " How can they rely on his letter, which he only wrote because
he was taken to task by us, in the matter of the unlawful ordination of Paulinianus and
his associates ; as in the opening of that very
letter he intimates ? " We have no such let- ter ! And what letter then is that, which in
its opening sentence speaks of Paulinianus?
There is something in the body of the letter of
which you are afraid to make mention. Well !
He was taken to task, you say, by you because
of the age of Paulinianus. But you yourself
ordain a man presbyter, and send him out as
an envoy and a colleague. You have the
boldness falsely to call Paulinianus a boy, and
then to send out your own boy presbyter.
You likewise take Theoseca, a deacon of the
church of Thiria, and make him presbyter,
and put weapons into his hands against us,
and make a misuse of his eloquence for our
injury. You alone are at liberty to trample
on the rights of the Church ; whatever you do,
is the standard of teaching ; and you do not
blush to challenge Epiphanius to stand with
you before the judgment seat of Christ. The
sequel of this passage is to the following effect:
1 he throws it in the teeth of Epiphanius that he was the partner of his table and an inmate
of his house, and declares that they never had
any talk together concerning the views of
Origen, and he supports what he says with the
attestation of an oath, saying : " He never showed, as God is witness, that he had even
the suspicion that our faith was not correct ? " I am unwilling to answer and argue acrimoni- ously, lest I seem to be convicting a bishop of
perjury. There are several letters of Epi-
phanius in our possession. One to John him- self, others to the bishops of Palestine, and one
of recent date to the pontiff of Rome ; and in
these he speaks of himself as impugning his
views in the presence of many, and says that
he was not thought worthy of a reply, " and
the whole Monastery," he says, "is witness to
what we in our insignificance assert."
lSee Letter LI., which begins as John says, though Jerome denies it.
AGAINST THE PELAGIANS:
DIALOGUE BETWEEN ATTICUS, A CATHOLIC, AND CRITOBULUS, A HERETIC.
The anti-Pelagian Dialogue is the last of Jerome's controversial works, having been written in the year 417, within three years of his death. It shows no lack of his old vigour, though perhaps something of the prolixity in- duced by old age. He looks at the subject more calmly than those of the previous treatises, mainly because it lay
somewhat outside the track of his own thoughts. He was induced to interest himself in it by his increasing regard
for Augustin, and by the coming of the young Spaniard, Orosius, in 414, from Augustin to sit at his feet.
Pelagius also had come to Palestine, and, after an investigation of his tenets, at a small council at Jerusalem, in