25. They had best have been silent; but since it
is otherwise, it remains to meet their shameless question with a bold
retort Vid.
Basil, contr. Eunom. ii. 17.. Perhaps on seeing the counter
absurdities which beset themselves, they may cease to fight against the
truth. After many prayers This
cautious and reverent way of speaking is a characteristic of S.
Athanasius, ad Serap. i. 1. vid. ii. init. ad Epict. 13
fin. ad Max. init. contr. Apoll. i. init. ‘I must
ask another question, bolder, yet with a religious intention; be
propitious, O Lord, &c.’ Orat. iii. 63, cf. de
Decr. 12, note 8, 15, note 6, de Syn. 51, note 4. then that God would
be gracious to us, thus we might ask them in turn; God who is, has He
so become, whereas He was not? or is He also before His coming into
being? whereas He is, did He make Himself, or is He of nothing, and
being nothing before, did He suddenly appear Himself? Unseemly is such
an enquiry, both unseemly and very blasphemous, yet parallel with
theirs; for the answer they make abounds in irreligion. But if it be
blasphemous and utterly irreligious thus to inquire about God, it will
be blasphemous too to make the like inquiries about His Word. However,
by way of exposing a question so senseless and so dull, it is necessary
to answer thus:—whereas God is, He was eternally; since then the
Father is ever, His Radiance ever is, which is His Word. And again, God
who is, hath from Himself His Word who also is; and neither hath the
Word been added, whereas He was not before, nor was the Father once
without Reason. For this assault upon the Son makes the blasphemy
recoil upon the Father; as if He devised for Himself a Wisdom, and
Word, and Son from without De
Decr. 25, note 2.; for whichever of
these titles you use, you denote the offspring from the Father, as has
been said. So that this their objection does not hold; and naturally;
for denying the Logos they in consequence ask questions which are
illogical. As then if a person saw the sun, and then inquired
concerning its radiance, and said, ‘Did that which is make that
which was, or that which was not,’ he would be held not to reason
sensibly, but to be utterly mazed, because he fancied what is from the
Light to be external to it, and was raising questions, when and where
and whether it were made; in like manner, thus to speculate concerning
the Son and the Father and thus to inquire, is far greater madness, for
it is to conceive of the Word of the Father as external to Him, and to
idly call the natural offspring a work, with the avowal, ‘He was
not before His generation.’ Nay, let them over and above take
this answer to their question;—The Father who was, made the Son
who was, for ‘the Word was made flesh John i. 14.;’ and, whereas He was Son of God, He
made Him in consummation of the ages also Son of Man, unless forsooth,
after the Samosatene, they affirm that He did not even exist at all,
till He became man.