The testimony of tradition is unanimous for the authenticity of
the first Epistle of Peter. It was known to Clement of Rome, Polycarp,
Papias, Hermas, &c. (the Muratorian Fragment, however, omits it),
and was cited under the name of Peter by Irenæus, Tertullian, and
Clement of Alexandria, from whose time its canonicity and Petrine
authorship were established, so that Eusebius rightly puts it among the
homologoumena. Semler, in 1784, was the first to deny its direct
Petrine authorship, and Cludius, in 1808, pronounced it absolutely
ungenuine. The Tübingen School followed, and at the present time
the genuineness is denied by all the negative critics, chiefly on
account of the strong Pauline character of the epistle (cf. Holtzmann,
Einleitung, p. 487 sqq., also Weiss, Einleitung, p. 428
sqq., who confines the resemblances to the Epistles to the Romans and
to the Ephesians, and denies the general Pauline character of the
epistle). The great majority of scholars, however, maintain the Petrine
authorship. A new opinion, expressed by Harnack, upon the assumption of
the distinctively Pauline character of the epistle, is that it was
written during the apostolic age by some follower of Paul, and that the
name of Peter was afterward attached to it, so that it represents no
fraud on the part of the writer, but an effort of a later age to find
an author for the anonymous epistle. In support of this is urged the
fact that though the epistle is so frequently quoted in the second
century, it is never connected with Peter’s name until the time
of Irenæus. (Cf. Harnack’s Lehre der Zwölf
Apostel, p. 106, note, and his Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 278,
note 2.) This theory has found few supporters.