§20. He does wrong in assuming, to account for the existence of the Only-Begotten, an
‘energy’ that produced Christ’s Person.
That such is his intention in using these phrases will be clear from what follows, where
he more plainly materializes and degrades our conception of the Son and of the Spirit. “As
the energies are bounded by the works, and the works commensurate with the energies, it
necessarily follows that these energies which accompany these Beings are relatively greater
and less, some being of a higher, some of a lower order.” Though he has studiously wrapt
the mist of his phraseology round the meaning of this, and made it hard for most to find
out, yet as following that which we have already examined it will easily be made clear. “The
energies,” he says, “are bounded by the works.” By ‘works’ he means the Son and the Spirit,
by ‘energies’ the efficient powers by which they were produced, which powers, he said a
little above, ‘follow’ the Beings. The phrase ‘bounded by’ expresses the balance which exists
between the being produced and the producing power, or rather the ‘energy’ of that power,
to use his own word implying that the thing produced is not the effect of the whole power
of the operator, but only of a particular energy of it, only so much of the whole power being
exerted as is calculated to be likely to be equal to effect that result. Then he inverts his
statement: “and the works are commensurate with the energies of the operators.” The
meaning of this will be made clearer by an illustration. Let us think of one of the tools of a
shoemaker: i.e., a leather-cutter. When it is moved round upon that from which a certain
shape has to be cut, the part so excised is limited by the size of the instrument, and a circle
of such a radius will be cut as the instrument possesses of length, and, to put the matter the
other way, the span of the instrument will measure and cut out a corresponding circle. That
is the idea which our theologian has of the divine person of the Only-begotten. He declares
that a certain ‘energy’ which ‘follows’ upon the first Being produced, in the fashion of such
a tool, a corresponding work, namely our Lord: this is his way of glorifying the Son of God,
Who is even now glorified in the glory of the Father, and shall be revealed in the Day of
Judgment. He is a ‘work commensurate with the producing energy.’ But what is this energy
which ‘follows’ the Almighty and is to be conceived of prior to the Only-begotten, and which
circumscribes His being? A certain essential Power, self-subsisting, which works its will by
a spontaneous impulse. It is this, then, that is the real Father of our Lord. And why do we
go on talking of the Almighty as the Father, if it was not He, but an energy belonging to the
things which follow Him externally that produced the Son: and how can the Son be a son
any longer, when something else has given Him existence according to Eunomius, and He
creeps like a bastard (may our Lord pardon the expression!) into relationship with the
Father, and is to be honoured in name only as a Son? How can Eunomius rank our Lord
next after the Almighty at all, when he counts Him third only, with that mediating ‘energy’
placed in the second place? The Holy Spirit also according to this sequence will be found
He does wrong in assuming, to account for the existence of the Only-Begotten, an 'energy' that produced Christ's Person.
110
He does wrong in assuming, to account for the existence of the Only-Begotten,…