I do not know that ever I met with any thing thus crudely
asserted among the Quakers, in contempt of the person of Christ; for
whereas he says of himself expressly, “I am the way, the truth, and the
life,” to say he is not so (for Jesus Christ is his person, and nothing
else), carries in it a bold contradiction, both parts of which cannot be
true. When the subject of a proposition is owned, there may be great
controversy about the sense of the predicate; as when Christ says he is the
vine: there may be so also about the subject of a proposition, when the
expression is of a third thing, and dubious; as where Christ says, “This is
my body:” but when the person speaking is the subject, and speaks of
himself, to deny what he says, is to give him the lie. “I am the way, the
truth, and the life,” saith Christ; — “He is not,” saith our author, “but
the gospel is so.” If he had allowed our Lord Jesus Christ to have spoken
the truth, but only to have added, “Though he was so, yet he was so no
otherwise but by the gospel,” there had been somewhat of modesty in the
expression; but this saying, that the “person of Christ is not, — the
gospel is so,” is intolerable. It is so, however, that this young man,
without consulting or despising the exposition of all divines, ancient or
modern, and the common sense of all Christians, should dare to obtrude his
crude and undigested conceptions upon so great a word of Christ himself,
countenanced only by the corrupt and false glosses of some obscure
Socinians: which some or other may possibly in due time mind him of; I have
other work to do.