Baronius (Am. IV. 272) and Valesius in this
passage agree in looking upon this whole story as a groundless fiction
which some pretended eyewitness palmed off on Socrates. The law
mentioned here is never mentioned by any other historian; no vestige of
it is found in any of the codes; on the contrary, according to Bingham
(Christ. Antiq. XVI. 11), bigamy and polygamy were treated with
the utmost severity in the ancient Church, and the Roman law was very
much against them; furthermore, Am. Marcellinus (XXX.) says that
Valentinian was remarkable for his chastity, both at home and abroad,
and Zosimus (IV. 19) that his second wife had been married to
Magnentius previously [and hence was not a virgin as here stated] and
that he married her after the death of his first wife; all of which
considerations taken together render it historically certain that the
story is not true.