484
24. If you will open your minds’ eyes, and see the real4204 truth without gratifying any
private end, you will find that the causes of all the miseries by which, as you say, the human
race has long been afflicted, flow from such beliefs which you held in former times about
your gods; and which you have refused to amend, although the truth was placed before your
eyes. For what about them, pray, have we indeed ever either imagined which was unbecoming,
or put forth in shameful writings that the troubles which assail men and the loss of the
blessings of life4205 should be used to excite a prejudice against us? Do we say that certain
gods were produced from eggs,4206 like storks and pigeons? Do we say that the radiant
Cytherean Venus grew up, having taken form from the sea’s foam and the severed genitals
of Cœlus? that Saturn was thrown into chains for parricide, and relieved from their weight
only on his own days?4207 that Jupiter was saved from death4208 by the services of the
Curetes? that he drove his father from the seat of power, and by force and fraud possessed
a sovereignty not his own? Do we say that his aged sire, when driven out, concealed himself
in the territories of the Itali, and gave his name as a gift to Latium,4209 because he had been
there protected from his son? Do we say that Jupiter himself incestuously married his sister?
or, instead of pork, breakfasted in ignorance upon the son of Lycaon, when invited to his
table? that Vulcan, limping on one foot, wrought as a smith in the island of Lemnos? that
Æsculapius was transfixed by a thunderbolt because of his greed and avarice, as the Bœotian
Pindar4210 sings? that Apollo, having become rich, by his ambiguous responses, deceived
the very kings by whose treasures and gifts he had been enriched? Did we declare that
Mercury was a thief? that Laverna is so also, and along with him presides over secret frauds?
Is the writer Myrtilus one of us, who declares that the Muses were the handmaids of Mega-
lcon,4211 daughter of Macarus?4212
4204 Orelli, without receiving into the text, approves of the reading of Stewechius, promptam, “evident,” for
the ms. propriam.
4205 Lit., “the benefits diminished by which it is lived.”
4206 The ms. reads ex Jovis; the first five edd. Jove—“from Jove,” which is altogether out of place; the others,
as above, ex ovis. Cf. i. 36.
4207 The ms. reads et ablui diebus tantis…elevari; LB., Hild. and Oehler, statis or statutis…et levari—“and
was loosed and released on fixed days;” Elm., Oberthür, and Orelli receive the conjecture of Ursinus, et suis
diebus tantum…rel., as above.
4208 Cf. iii. [cap. 41, p. 475, and cap. 30, p. 472].
4209 i.e., hiding-place. Virg., Æn., viii. 322: Quoniam latuisset tutus in oris.
4210 Pyth., iii. 102 sq.
4211 ms. Meglac.
4212 The ms. and most edd. give filias, making the Muses daughters of Macarus; but Orelli, Hild., and Oehler
adopt, as above, the reading of Canterus, filiæ, in accordance with Clem. Alex.
Chapter XXIV.
1156
Chapter XXIV.