therefore, did no evil themselves, but in all this were innocent sufferers. The real agent was
he who sent them away from himself into this wretchedness. They suffered more from their
father than from their enemy. Their father sent them into all this misery; while their enemy
desired them as something good, wishing not to hurt them, but to enjoy them. The one
injured them knowingly, the other in ignorance. This god was so weak and helpless that he
could not otherwise secure himself first against an enemy threatening attack, and then
against the same enemy in confinement. Let him, then, not condemn those parts whose
obedience defended him, and whose death secures his safety. If he could not avoid the
conflict, why slander his defenders? When these parts allowed themselves to be led astray
from their original brightness, and became hostile to sacred light, this must have been from
the force of the enemy; and if they were forced against their will, they are innocent; while,
if they could have resisted had they chosen, there is no need of the origin of evil in an ima-
ginary evil nature, since it is to be found in free-will. Their not resisting, when they could
have done so, is plainly their own fault, and not owing to any force from without. For,
supposing them able to do a thing, to do which is right, while not to do it is great and heinous
sin, their not doing it is their own choice. So, then, if they choose not to do it, the fault is
in their will not in necessity. The origin of sin is in the will; therefore in the will is also the
origin of evil, both in the sense of acting against a just precept, and in the sense of suffering
under a just sentence. There is thus no reason why, in your search for the origin of evil, you
should fall into so great an evil as that of calling a nature so rich in good things the nature
of evil, and of attributing the terrible evil of necessity to the nature of perfect good, before
any commixture with evil. The cause of this erroneous belief is your pride, which you need
not have unless you choose; but in your wish to defend at all hazards the error into which
282
you have fallen, you take away the origin of evil from free-will, and place it in a fabulous
nature of evil. And thus you come at last to say, that the souls which are to be doomed to
eternal confinement in the mass of darkness became enemies to sacred light not from choice,
but by necessity; and to make your god a judge with whom it is of no use to prove, in behalf
of your clients. that they were under compulsion, and a king who will make no allowance
for your brethren, his own sons and members, whose hostility against you and against
himself you ascribe not to choice, but to necessity. What shocking cruelty! unless you proceed
in the next place to defend your god, as also acting not from choice, but by necessity. So, if
there could be found another judge free from necessity, who could decide the question on
the principles of equity, he would sentence your god to be bound to this mass, not by being
fastened on the outside, but by being shut up inside along with the formidable enemy. The
first in the guilt of necessity ought to be first in the sentence of condemnation. Would it
not be much better, then, in comparison with such a god as this, to choose the god whom
we indeed do not worship, but whom you think or pretend to think we worship? Though
he spares not his servants, whether righteous or sinful, making no proper separation, and
480
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…