(d) Council of Sardica and death of
Gregory. The confusion into which the whole chronology of the
surrounding events was thrown by the supposition (which was naturally
taken without question upon the authority of Socrates and Sozomen) that
the Sardican council met in 347, is reflected in the careful digest of
opinions made by Newman (Arians, Appendix, or better,
Introduction to Hist. Treatises of S. Ath. p. xxvi.; cf. also
Hefele, Eng. Tra., vol. 2, p. 188, sq., notes), and especially
in the difficulties caused by the necessity of placing the Council of
Milan in 345 before Sardica, and the mission of Euphrates of Cologne to
Antioch as late as 348. Now the Hist. Aceph., by giving October,
346, as the date of the return of Athanasius from his second exile, at
once challenged the received date for Sardica, and J. D. Mansi, the
learned editor of the ‘Collectio Amplissima’ of the
Councils, used this fact as the key to unlock the chronological tangle
of the period. He argued that the Council of Sardica must be put back
at least as early as 344; but the natural conservatism of learning
resisted his conclusions until the year 1852, when the Festal
Letters, discovered ten years earlier, were made available for the
theological public of Europe. The date 347 was then finally condemned.
Not only did Letter 18, written at Easter, 345, refer to the
Council’s decision about Easter, and Letter 19 refer to
his restoration as an accomplished fact; the Index most positively
dated the synod in the year 343, which year has now taken its place as
the accepted date, although the month and duration of the assembly are
still open to doubt (Supr. p. xlv., note 6). In any case it is
certain that the Easter at which the deputies from Constans and the Council reached
Antioch was Easter, 344. This brings us to the question of the date of
Gregory’s death. Mr. Gwatkin rightly connects the Council which
deposed Stephen for his behaviour to the Western deputies, and elected
Leontius, with the issue of the ‘Macrostich’ creed
‘three years’ (de Syn. 26) after the Council of the
Dedication, i.e., in the summer of 344. This is our only notice of time
for the Council in question, and it is not very precise; but the
Council may fairly be placed in the early summer, which would allow
time for the necessary preliminaries after Easter, and for the meeting
of the fathers at reasonable notice. (Perhaps Stephen was promptly
and informally deposed (Thdt.) after Easter, but a regular council
would be required to ratify this act and to elect his successor.) After
the Council (we are again not told how long after) Constantius writes a
public letter to Alexandria forbidding further persecution of the
orthodox (277, note 3). This may well have been in the later summer of
344. Then ‘about ten months later’ (ib.) Gregory
dies. This would bring us ‘about’ to the early summer of
345; and this rough calculation The above
resumé of the details of the evidence makes it clear that
Mr. Gwatkin’s alleged oversights are in reality those of his
critic. The proposal of the latter to correct ‘Epiph.’ in
Fest. Ind. to ‘Pharmuthi’ is especially
gratuitous. is curiously confirmed
by the precise statement of the Index xviii., that Gregory died
on June 26 (345, although the Index, in accordance with its
principle of arrangement, which will be explained in the proper place,
puts the notice under the following year). Of course the date of the
letter of Constantius, which Athanasius gives as the terminus a
quo of the ‘ten months,’ cannot be fixed except by
conjecture, and the date given by the Index is (1) the only
precise statement we have, (2) is likely enough in itself, and (3)
agrees perfectly with the datum of de Synod 26. That is to say,
as far as our evidence goes it appears to be correct.