Chapter 15.—24. Crescens of Cirta1636 said: "The letters of our most beloved Cyprian
to Jubaianus, and also to Stephen,1637 having been read in so large an assembly of our most
holy brethren in the priesthood, containing as they do so large a body of sacred testimony
derived from the Scriptures that give us our God,1638 that we have every reason to assent
to them, being all united by the grace of God, I give my judgment that all heretics or schis-
matics who wish to come to the Catholic Church should not enter therein unless they have
been first exorcised and baptized; with the obvious exception of those who have been origin-
ally baptized in the Catholic Church, these being reconciled and admitted to the penance
of the Church by the imposition of hands."1639
25. Here we are warned once more to inquire why he says, "Except, of course, those
who have been originally baptized in the Catholic Church." Is it because they had not lost
what they had before received? Why then could they not also transmit outside the Church
what they were able to possess outside? Is it that outside it is unlawfully transmitted? But
neither is it lawfully possessed outside, and yet it is possessed; so it is unlawfully given outside,
but yet it is given. But what is given to the person returning from heresy who had been
baptized inside, is given to the person coming to the Church who had been baptized out-
side,—that is, that he may have lawfully inside what before he had unlawfully outside. But
perhaps some one may ask what was said on this point in the letter of the blessed Cyprian
to Stephen, which is mentioned in this judgment, though not in the opening address to the
Council,—I suppose because it was not considered necessary. For Crescens stated that the
letter itself had been read in the assembly, which I have no doubt was done, if I am not
mistaken, as is customary, in order that the bishops, being already assembled, might receive
some information at the same time on the subject contained in that letter. For it certainly
has no bearing on the present subject; and I am more surprised at Crescens having thought
fit to mention it at all, than at its having been passed over in the opening address. But if
any one thinks that I have shrunk from bringing forward something which has been urged
in it that is essential to the present point, let him read it and see that what I say is true; or if
he finds it otherwise, let him convict me of falsehood. For that letter contains nothing
whatsoever about baptism administered among heretics or schismatics, which is the subject
of our present argument.1640
1636 Cirta, an inland city of the Massylii in Numidia, was rebuilt by Constantine, and called Constantina.
1637 See below, on sec. 25.
1638 Ex Scripturis deificis.
1639 Conc. Carth. sec. 8.
1640 There are two letters extant from Cyprian to Stephen, No. 68, respecting Marcianus of Arles, who had
joined Novatian, and No. 72, on a Council concerning heretical baptism. It is clear, however, from Ep. lxxiv. 1,
that this Council, and consequently the letter to Stephen, was subsequent to the Council under consideration;
and consequently Augustin is right in ignoring it, and referring solely to the former. Dr. Routh thinks the words
Chapter 15
882
Chapter 15