184 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1857-8
judge for others, one must do what one felt right, but
certainly he could not communicate with the German
Lutherans, and he thought Dean Alford had made a mis-
take when he did so, which he (Mr. Maurice) regretted.
This somewhat posed me. I said, " Well, I am not looking
at the question as it regards clergymen ; possibly their
position might be somewhat different from that of laymen."
" I think it might," he said, " and altogether I should not
like to give a positive answer on such a subject as this
without taking time to think it over." I said, " Of course
I am not discussing the question theoretically or as it bears
upon clergymen, but as regards my own duty. For myself,
I cannot help feeling that being already a communicant
among the Unitarians, and they being regarded in the
light they are by other Christians, my withdrawal from
Communion with them would be equivalent to saying that
I no longer regarded them as Christian brethren. If
I had never communicated anywhere, and had now to
make my choice for the first time, the case would be quite
different." He said, " I don't see that your withdrawing,
&c., involves anything of the kind. Might it not rather be
a declaring to them that you see more in the rite than
they do ; that to you it essentially involves an idea of
sacrifice which they do not receive ; and rather have the
effect of suggesting to them thatyou hold something higher,
than that you wish to condemn them ?
"
I said, " If
there were any expression in their service which I disagreed
with, the case would be different, but there is nothing that
offends me ; only a lack : and I cannot feel as if that were
a justification."
On one point, I do feel quite clear that I differ from
Mr. Maurice. I do regard the Communion as the sign of
Christian brotherhood, and think that we should be (or at
least feel that I should be) ready to communicate with all
to whom one does not deny that brotherhood. Mr. Maurice
says
: Yes ; if they will join me in celebrating the rite after
my fashion. I say : Yes, I will join with them, providing
that they admit me without asking me to do or say any-