Chapter 15.—23. To go on to the point which he pursues at great length, that "they who
blaspheme the Father of Christ cannot be baptized in Christ,"1435 since it is clear that they
blaspheme through error (for he who comes to the baptism of Christ will not openly blas-
pheme the Father of Christ, but he is led to blaspheme by holding a view contrary to the
teaching of the truth about the Father of Christ), we have already shown at sufficient length
457
that baptism, consecrated in the words of the gospel, is not affected by the error of any man,
whether ministrant or recipient, whether he hold views contrary to the revelation of divine
teaching on the subject of the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Ghost. For many carnal and
natural men are baptized even within the Church, as the apostle expressly says: "The natural
man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God;"1436 and after they had received baptism,
he says that they "are yet carnal."1437 But according to it carnal sense, a soul given up to
fleshly appetites cannot entertain but fleshly wisdom about God. Wherefore many, progress-
ing after baptism, and especially those who have been baptized in infancy or early youth, in
proportion as their intellect becomes clearer and brighter, while "the inward man is renewed
day by day,"1438 throw away their former opinions which they held about God while they
were mocked with vain imaginings, with scorn and horror and confession of their mistake.
And yet they are not therefore considered not to have received baptism, or to have received
baptism of a kind corresponding to their error; but in them both the perfection of the sacra-
ment is honored and the delusion of their mind is corrected, even though it had become
inveterate through long confirmation, or been, perhaps, maintained in many controversies.
Wherefore even the heretic, who is manifestly without, if he has there received baptism as
ordained in the gospel, has certainly not received baptism of a kind corresponding to the
error which blinds him. And therefore, in returning into the way of wisdom he perceives
that he ought to relinquish what he has held amiss, he must not at the same time give up
the good which he had received; nor because his error is to be condemned, is the baptism
of Christ in him to be therefore extinguished. For it is already sufficiently clear, from the
case of those who happen to be baptized within the Church with false views about God, that
the truth of the sacrament is to be distinguished from the error of him who believes amiss,
although both may be found in the same man. And therefore, when any one grounded in
any error, even outside the Church, has yet been baptized with the true sacrament, when
he is restored to the unity of the Church, a true baptism cannot take the place of a true
baptism, as a true faith takes the place of a false one, because a thing cannot take the place
of itself, since neither can it give place. Heretics therefore join the Catholic Church to this
1435 Ib. Ep. lxxiii. 17.
1436 1 Cor. ii. 14.
1437 1 Cor. iii. 3.
1438 2 Cor. iv. 16.
Chapter 15
808
Chapter 15