The exact date of the rise of Montanism cannot be determined. The
reports which we have of the movement vary greatly in their chronology.
We have no means of fixing the date of the proconsulship of the Gratus
referred to here, and thus the most exact and reliable statement which
we have does not help us. In his Chron. Eusebius fixes the rise
of the movement in the year 172, and it is possible that this statement
was based upon a knowledge of the time of Gratus’ proconsulship.
If so, it possesses considerable weight. The first notice we have of a
knowledge of the movement in the West is in connection with the martyrs
of Lyons, who in the year 177 (see Introd. to this book, note 3) were
solicited to use their influence with the bishop of Rome in favor of
the Montanists (see above, chap. 3, note 6). This goes to confirm the
approximate accuracy of the date given by Eusebius, for we should
expect that the movement cannot have attracted public notice in the
East very many years before it was heard of in Gaul, the home of many
Christians from Asia Minor. Epiphanius (Hær. XLVIII.) gives
the nineteenth year of Antoninus Pius (156–157) as the date of
its beginning, but Epiphanius’ figures are very confused and
contradictory, and little reliance can be placed upon them in this
connection. At the same time Montanus must have begun his prophesying
some years before his teaching spread over Asia Minor and began to
agitate the churches and alarm the bishops, and therefore it is
probable that Montanism had a beginning some years before the date
given by Eusebius; in fact, it is not impossible that Montanus may have
begun his work before the end of the reign of Antoninus
Pius.