There is no absolutely
conclusive evidence as to the date of these Discourses, in fact they
would appear from the language of ii. 1 to have been issued at
intervals. The best judges, however, are agreed in assigning them to
the fruitful period of the ‘third exile.’ The Discourses
cannot indeed be identified with the lost account of the Arian heresy
addressed to certain Egyptian monks (see Introd. to Arian Hist.
supra); but the demand for such a treatise may have set
Athanasius upon the composition of a more comprehensive refutation of
the heresy. It was only at this period (‘Blasphemy’ of
Sirmium, 357) that the doctrinal controversy began to emerge from the
mass of personalities and intrigues which had encumbered it for the
first generation after the great Council; only now that the various
parties were beginning to formulate their position; only now that the
great mass of Eastern ‘Conservatism’ was beginning to see
the nature of the issue as between the Nicene doctrine and the
essential Arianism of its more resolute opponents. The situation seemed
to clear, the time had come for gathering up the issues of the combat
and striking a decisive blow. To this situation of affairs the treatise
before us exactly corresponds. Characteristic of this period is the
anxiety to conciliate and win over the so-called semi-Arians (of the
type of Basil of Ancyra) who stumbled at the ὁμοούσιον,
but whose fundamental agreement with Athanasius was daily becoming more
clear. Accordingly we find that Athanasius pointedly avoids the famous
test word in these Discourses Not
that he was willing to suppress the term and surrender the Nicene
cause, far from it; but he sees the relative importance of things and
words. This shews the absurdity of the taunt, that the Nicene
theologians fought ferociously over a single
‘iota.’ (with the exception
of the fourth: see Orat. i. 20, note 5, 58, note 10: it only
occurs i. 9, note 12, but see Orat. iv. 9, 12), and even adopts
(not as fully adequate de Syn. 53, but as true so far as it
goes), the ‘semi-Arian’ formula ‘like in
essence’ (Or. i. 21, note 8, 20, 26, iii. 26, he does not
use the single compound word ὁμοιούσιος:
see further, Introd. to de Synodis). Although, therefore,
demonstrative proof is lacking, there is tolerable certainty as to the
date of our Discourses. And their purpose is no less manifest: they are
a decisive blow of the kind described above, aimed at the very centre
of the question, and calculated to sever the abnormal alliance between
conservatives who really thought with Athanasius and men like Valens or
Eudoxius, whose real convictions, so far as they had any, were Arian.
Moreover they gather up all the threads of controversy against Arianism
proper, refute its appeal to Scripture, and leave on record for all
time the issues of the great doctrinal contest of the fourth century.
They have naturally become, as Montfaucon observes, the mine whence
subsequent defenders of the Divinity of our Redeemer have drawn their
material. There are doubtless arguments which a modern writer would
scarcely adopt (e.g. ii. 63, iii. 65 init., &c.), and the
repeated labelling of the Arians as madmen (‘fanatics’ in
this translation), enemies of Christ, disciples of Satan, &c.,
&c., is at once tedious and by its very frequency unimpressive (see
ii. 43 note 8 for Newman’s famous list of animal nicknames). But
the serious reader will pass sicco pede over such features, and
will appreciate ‘the richness, fulness, and versatility’ of
the use of Scripture, ‘the steady grasp of certain primary
truths, especially of the Divine Unity and of Christ’s real or
genuine natural and Divine Sonship (i. 15, ii. 2–5, 22, 23, 73,
iii. 62), the keen penetration with which Arian objections are analysed
(i. 14, 27, 29, ii. 26, iii. 59), Arian imputations disclaimed, Arian
statements old and new, the bolder and the more cautious, compared,
Arian evasions pointed out, Arian logic traced to its conclusions, and
Arianism shewn to be inconsistent, irreverent’ (Bright, Introd.
p. lxviii.). Above all, we see in these Discourses what strikes us in all the
writings of Athanasius from the de Incarnatione to the end, his
firm hold of the Soteriological aspect of the question at issue, of its
vital importance to the reality of Redemption and Grace, to the reality
of the knowledge of God vouchsafed to sinful man in Christ (ii. 69, 70,
cf. i. 35, 49, 50, ii. 67, &c., &c). The Theology and
Christology of Athanasius is rooted in the idea of Redemption: our
fellowship with God, our adoption as sons of God, would be
unaccomplished, had not Christ imparted to us what was His Own to give (i. 12, 16, cf. Harnack,
Dogmengesch., 2. 205). Among other points of interest we may
observe the anticipatory rejection of the later heresies of Macedonius
(i. 48, iii. 24), Nestorius (ii. 8 note 3, &c., and the frequent
application of θεοτόκος to the
B.M.V. iii. 14, 29, &c.), and Eutyches (ii. 10 note 6, &c.),
the emphatic vindication of worship as the exclusive prerogative of
Divinity (ii. 23, iii. 32, ‘we invoke no creature’)
and of the unique sinless conception of Christ (iii. 33), lastly
the cautious and reasonable discussion (iii. 42 sqq.) of our
Saviour’s human knowledge.