compel those to confess him who were then present for the purpose of proving and reasoning
233
with the talkative spirit,—those eminent men and bishops, Zoticus,1596 from the village
Comana, and Julian,1597 from Apamea, whose mouths the followers of Themiso1598 muzzled,
refusing to permit the false and seductive spirit to be refuted by them.”
18. Again in the same work, after saying other things in refutation of the false prophecies
of Maximilla, he indicates the time when he wrote these accounts, and mentions her predic-
tions in which she prophesied wars and anarchy. Their falsehood he censures in the following
manner:
19. “And has not this been shown clearly to be false? For it is to-day more than thirteen
years since the woman died, and there has been neither a partial nor general war in the
world; but rather, through the mercy of God, continued peace even to the Christians.”1599
These things are taken from the second book.
20. I will add also short extracts from the third book, in which he speaks thus against
their boasts that many of them had suffered martyrdom:
1596 Of this Bishop Zoticus we know only what is told us here and in chap. 18, §13. On the proposed identi-
fication of Zoticus and Sotas, bishop of Anchialus, see chap. 19, note 10. Comana (Κομ€νης, according to most
of the mss. and editors; Κουμ€νης, according to a few of the mss. followed by Laemmer and Heinichen) was a
village of Pamphylia, and is to be distinguished from Comana in Pontus and from Comana in Cappadocia
(Armenia), both of which were populous and important cities.
1597 Of this Julian we know nothing more. His city was Apamea Cibotus or Ciboti, which, according to
Wiltsch, was a small town on Mount Signia in Pisidia, to be distinguished from the important Phrygian Apamea
Cibotus on the Mæander. Whether Wiltsch has good grounds for this distinction I am unable to say. It would
certainly seem natural to think in the present case of Apamea on the Mæander, inasmuch as it is spoken of
without any qualifying phrase, as if there could be no doubt about its identity.
1598 Themiso is mentioned again in chap. 18 as a confessor, and as the author of a catholic epistle. It is plain
that he was a prominent man among the Montanists in the time of our anonymous author, that is, after the
death of Montanus himself; and it is quite likely that he was, as Salmon suggests, the head of the sect.
1599 This gives us a clear indication of the date of the composition of this anonymous work. The thirteen
years must fall either before the wars which began in the reign of Septimius Severus, or after their completion.
The earliest possible date in the latter case is 232, and this is certainly much too late for the composition of this
work, which speaks of Montanism more than once as a recent thing, and which it seems clear from other indic-
ations belongs rather to the earlier period of the movement. If we put its composition before those wars, we
cannot place it later than 192, the close of the reign of Commodus. This would push the date of Maximilla’s
death back to 179, which though it seems rather early, is not at all impossible. The period from about 179 to 192
might very well be called a time of peace by the Christians; for no serious wars occurred during that interval,
and we know that the Christians were left comparatively undisturbed throughout the reign of Commodus.
551
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.