The
principle, that there should be only one bishop in a city, was not
clearly enunciated and forcibly emphasized until the third century.
Cyprian’s writings are full of it (cf. his treatise On the
Unity of the Church), and in connection with this Novatian schism,
which showed so plainly the disintegrating effects of a division of the
church under two bishops, the principle was established so firmly as
never again to be questioned. I do not mean to assert here that the
principle so clearly and conclusively established at this time was a
new principle. We find it enunciated even by Ignatius at the beginning
of the second century, and it was the common opinion of Christendom, or
otherwise Cyprian could not have appealed to universal custom as he
does in discussing the matter. I mean simply that the principle had
never before been brought to such a test as to require its formal
enunciation and public recognition by the clergy and the Church at
large. The emergency which now arose compelled such formal statement of
it; and the Council of Nicæa made it canon law (cf.
Bingham’s Antiquities, I. p. 160 sq.).