19. Another personal promise to Peter, remarkably fulfilled in his being the first to admit both Jews and Gentiles into the Church; thus using the power of the keys to open the door of salvation. As an instance of his shutting it also, witness his speech to Simon Magus,— οὐκἔστινσοιμερὶςοὐδὲκλῆροςἐντῷλόγῳτούτῳ, Acts 8:21. Those who deny the reference of Mat 16:18 to St. Peter, will find it very difficult to persuade any unbiassed Greek scholar, that the καὶδώσωσοί, with ó ï é thus lying unemphatically behind the verb, is not a continuation of a previous address, but a change of address altogether.
ὃἂνδήσῃςκ. ô. ë.] This same promise is repeated in ch. Matthew 18:18, to all the disciples generally, and to any two or three gathered together in Christ’s name. It was first however verified, and in a remarkable and prominent way, to Peter. Of the binding, the case of Ananias and Sapphira may serve as an eminent example: of the loosing, the ὃἔχω, τοῦτόσοιδίδωμι, to the lame man at the Beautiful gate of the Temple. But strictly considered, the binding and loosing belong to the power of legislation in the Church committed to the Apostles, in accordance with the Jewish way of using the words אסרand התירfor prohibuit and licitum fecit. They cannot relate to the remission and retention of sins, for (as Meyer observes) though λύεινἁμαρτίας certainly appears (reff.
LXX) to mean to forgive sins, δέεινἁμαρτ. for retaining them would be altogether without example, and, I may add, would bear no meaning in the interpretation: it is not the sin, but the sinner, that is bound, ἔνοχοςαἰωνίουἁμαρτήματος (Mark 3:29). Nor can the ancient custom of fastening doors by means of cord be alluded to; for the expressions, ὃἄν, ὃἐάν, clearly indicate something bound and something loosed, and not merely the power of the keys just conferred. The meaning in John 20:23, though an expansion of this in one particular direction (see note there), is not to be confounded with this.