7. Among these is inserted also another epistle addressed to the Cnosians,1258 in which
he exhorts Pinytus, bishop of the parish, not to lay upon the brethren a grievous and com-
pulsory burden in regard to chastity, but to have regard to the weakness of the multitude.
8. Pinytus, replying to this epistle, admires and commends Dionysius, but exhorts him
in turn to impart some time more solid food, and to feed the people under him, when he
wrote again, with more advanced teaching, that they might not be fed continually on these
milky doctrines and imperceptibly grow old under a training calculated for children. In this
epistle also Pinytus’ orthodoxy in the faith and his care for the welfare of those placed under
him, his learning and his comprehension of divine things, are revealed as in a most perfect
image.
9. There is extant also another epistle written by Dionysius to the Romans, and addressed
to Soter,1259 who was bishop at that time. We cannot do better than to subjoin some passages
from this epistle, in which he commends the practice of the Romans which has been retained
down to the persecution in our own days. His words are as follows:
10. “For from the beginning it has been your practice to do good to all the brethren in
various ways, and to send contributions to many churches in every city. Thus relieving the
want of the needy, and making provision for the brethren in the mines by the gifts which
churches of Pontus and Crete. It was probably in consequence of reaction against their strict discipline that he
advocated the readmission to the Church of excommunicated offenders, in this anticipating the later practice
of the Roman church, which was introduced by Callixtus and soon afterward became general, though not without
bitter opposition from many quarters. Harnack (Dogmengeschichte, p. 332, note 4) throws doubt upon the cor-
rectness of this report of Eusebius; but such doubt is unwarranted, for Eusebius had Dionysius’ epistle before
him, and the position which he represents him as taking is quite in accord with the mildness which he recommends
to Pinytus, and is therefore just what we should expect. The fact that Callixtus’ principle is looked upon by
Tertullian and Hippolytus as an innovation does not militate at all against the possibility that Dionysius in
Corinth, or other individuals in other minor churches, held the same principles some time before.
1258 Cnossus, or Cnosus, was the capital city of Crete. This epistle is no longer extant, nor do we know anything
about Pinytus himself except what is told us here and in chap. 21, above, where he is mentioned among the ec-
clesiastical writers of the day. Jerome (de vir. ill. 28) only repeats what Eusebius says, and Rufinus, in stating
that Pinytus was convinced by the epistle of Dionysius and changed his course, seems simply to have misunder-
stood what Eusebius says about his admiration for and praise of Dionysius. It is evident from the tone of his
reply that Pinytus was not led by Dionysius’ epistle to agree with him.
1259 On Soter, see chap. 19, note 2. This practice of the Roman church combined with other causes to secure
it that position of influence and prominence which resulted in the primacy of its bishop, and finally in the
papacy. The position of the Roman church, as well as its prosperity and numerical strength, gave it early a feeling
that it was called upon in an especial way to exercise oversight and to care for weaker sister churches, and thus
its own good offices helped to promote its influence and its power.
455
Dionysius, Bishop of Corinth, and the Epistles which he wrote.