143. c.) So he allows, that they must not only be endowed with christian piety in appearance;
but that they must be so in profession. (p. 3. a. p. 41. e. p. 44. d.) That they make a show of
being wise virgins by the nature and purport of their profession. (p. 42. b.) And he insists
with great strenuousness, over and over, upon its being their scheme, that they ought to
make a profession of real saintship. (p. 132. a. c. d.) Yea, he holds, that there must be not
only some visibility and profession of real piety, but moral evidence of it. (p. 139. d.) He
often uses notes of distinction, distinguishing between moral sincerity and real piety; and
insists much upon it as belonging to their scheme, that there must be a visibility of the latter,
as thus distinguished from the former. So, he rejects with great contempt any suggestion of
its being the scheme of my opposers, that moral sincerity is that saintship, which is to be
professed and made visible; and in distinction from this, he asserts, that it is real holiness.
(p. 4. d. e. and p. 5. a. b.) And again (p. 35. c.) he uses a note of distinction, and insists that
the opposers of my opinion hold, that communicants must make a profession of something
more than common grace and moral sincerity. And again (p. 139. a. d.) he uses notes of
discrimination, and says, that they must exhibit a credible profession of gospel-holiness,
and not merely of moral sincerity; and says, it is not the visibility of moral sincerity, but the
moral evidence of gospel-sincerity, which God’s word makes the rule of judging.—And as
he holds, that communicants must profess gospel-holiness, so he seems to suppose that
these professors must judge this of themselves; several things he says, seem plainly to imply
it. This appears evidently implied in that interrogation put by Mr. W. (p. 35. e.) “Mr. S.
rightly supposes all visible saints who are not truly pious, to be hypocrites; and the Scripture
supposes and calls them so too: but will it therefore follow, that all hypocrites know they
are so?” And he in effect asserts, that men should look at such a qualification, as sanctifying
grace, in themselves, and inquire whether they have it, or no, in order to determine whether
they should present themselves to gospel-ordinances: for he greatly finds fault with me for
suggesting, as if those of a different opinion from me supposed, that persons have no manner
of need to look at any such qualification in themselves, or at all inquire, whether they have
it, in order to present themselves to sacraments. He refers to that passage in my book, (p.
55. d.) “ I cannot conceive what should move Philip to utter those words, or what he should
aim at in them, if he at the same time supposed that the eunuch had no manner of need to
look at any such qualification in himself, or at all to inquire whether he had such a faith, or
no, in order to determine whether he might present himself as the subject of baptism.” It is
plain, the qualification I have respect to, is grace, or saving faith. And so Mr. W, himself
understands me; as appears by his reflections, (p. 49. c. d. e.) where, after quoting this passage,
he consigns me over to another judgment, for suggesting that my opposers hold what I had
there expressed, and for “representing the matter, as if they looked on it as no matter
1916
SECTION I. His concessions.