It
is quite likely, as Salmon suggests (in the Dict. of Christ.
Biog.), that Dionysius, who wrote against Marcion in this epistle
to the Nicomedians, also had Marcionism in view in writing on life and
discipline to the churches of Pontus and Crete. It was probably in
consequence of reaction against their strict discipline that he
advocated the readmission to the Church of excommunicated offenders, in
this anticipating the later practice of the Roman church, which was
introduced by Callixtus and soon afterward became general, though not
without bitter opposition from many quarters. Harnack
(Dogmengeschichte, p. 332, note 4) throws doubt upon the
correctness of this report of Eusebius; but such doubt is unwarranted,
for Eusebius had Dionysius’ epistle before him, and the position
which he represents him as taking is quite in accord with the mildness
which he recommends to Pinytus, and is therefore just what we should
expect. The fact that Callixtus’ principle is looked upon by
Tertullian and Hippolytus as an innovation does not militate at all
against the possibility that Dionysius in Corinth, or other individuals
in other minor churches, held the same principles some time
before.