34. All that goes for nothing, says Jovinianus, because
even bishops, priests, and deacons, husbands of one wife, and having
children, were appointed by the Apostle. Just as the Apostle 1 Cor. vii. 25. says he has no commandment
respecting virgins, and yet gives his advice, as one who had obtained
mercy from the Lord, and is anxious throughout the whole discussion to
give virginity the preference over marriage, and advises what he does
not venture to command, lest he seem to lay a snare, and to put a
heavier burden upon man’s nature than it can bear; so also in
establishing the constitution of the Church, inasmuch as the elements
of the early Church were drawn from the Gentiles, he made the rules for
fresh believers somewhat lighter that they might not in alarm shrink
from keeping them. Then, again, the Apostles and elders wrote Acts xv. 28, 29. letters from Jerusalem that no heavier
burden should be laid on Gentile believers than that they should keep
themselves from idolatry, and from fornication, and from things
strangled. As though they were providing for infant children, they gave
them milk to drink, not solid food. Nor did they lay down rules for
continence, nor hint at virginity, nor urge to fasting, nor repeat the
directions S. Matt. x. 10: S. Luke x. 5. given in the Gospel to the
Apostles, not to have two tunics, nor scrip, nor money in their
girdles, nor staff in their hand, nor shoes on their feet. And they
certainly did not bid them, S. Matt. xix. 21. if they
wished to be perfect, go and sell all that they had and give to the
poor, and “come follow me.” For if the young man who
boasted of having done all that the law enjoins, when he heard this
went away sorrowful, because he had great possessions, and the
Pharisees derided an utterance such as this from our Lord’s lips:
how much more would the vast multitude of Gentiles, whose highest
virtue consisted in not plundering another’s goods, have
repudiated the obligation of perpetual chastity and continence, when
they were told in the letter to keep themselves from idols, and from
fornication, seeing that fornication was heard of among them, and such
fornication as was not “even among the Gentiles.” But the
very choice of a bishop makes for me. For he does not say: Let a bishop
be chosen who marries one wife and begets children; but who marries one
wife, and 1 Tim. iii. 2, 4; Tit. i. 6. has his children in subjection
and well disciplined. You surely admit that he is no bishop who during
his episcopate begets children. The reverse is the case—if he be
discovered, he will not be bound by the ordinary obligations of a
husband, but will be condemned as an adulterer. Either permit Sacerdotes: that
is, bishops. priests to perform the work of
marriage with the result that virginity and marriage are on a par: or
if it is unlawful for priests to touch their wives, they are so far
holy in that they imitate virgin chastity. But something more follows.
A layman, or any believer, cannot pray unless he abstain from sexual
intercourse. Now a priest must
always offer sacrifices for the people: he must therefore always pray.
And if he must always pray, he must always be released from the duties
of marriage. For even under the old law they who used to offer
sacrifices for the people not only remained in their houses, but
purified themselves for the occasion by separating from their wives,
nor would they drink wine or strong drink which are wont to stimulate
lust. That married men are elected to the priesthood, I do not deny:
the number of virgins is not so great as that of the priests required.
Does it follow that because all the strongest men are chosen for the
army, weaker men should not be taken as well? All cannot be strong. If
an army were constituted of strength only, and numbers went for
nothing, the feebler men might be rejected. As it is, men of second or
third-rate strength are chosen, that the army may have its full
numerical complement. How is it, then, you will say, that frequently at
the ordination of priests a virgin is passed over, and a married man
taken? Perhaps because he lacks other qualifications in keeping with
virginity, or it may be that he is thought a virgin, and is not: or
there may be a stigma on his virginity, or at all events virginity
itself makes him proud, and while he plumes himself on mere bodily
chastity, he neglects other virtues; he does not cherish the poor: he
is too fond of money. It sometimes happens that a man has a gloomy
visage, a frowning brow, a walk as though he were in a solemn
procession, and so offends the people, who, because they have no fault
to find with his life, hate his mere dress and gait. Many are chosen
not out of affection for themselves, but out of hatred for another. In
most cases the election is won by mere simplicity, while the shrewdness
and discretion of another candidate elicit opposition as though they
were evils. Sometimes the judgement of the commoner people is at fault,
and in testing the qualities of the priesthood, the individual inclines
to his own character, with the result that he looks not so much for a
good candidate as for one like himself. Not unfrequently it happens
that married men, who form the larger portion of the people, in
approving married candidates seem to approve themselves, and it does
not occur to them that the mere fact that they prefer a married person
to a virgin is evidence of their inferiority to virgins. What I am
going to say will perhaps offend many. Yet I will say it, and good men
will not be angry with me, because they will not feel the sting of
conscience. Sometimes it is the fault of the bishops, who choose into
the ranks of the clergy not the best, but the cleverest, men, and think
the more simple as well as innocent ones incapable; or, as though they
were distributing the offices of an earthly service, they give posts to
their kindred and relations; or they listen to the dictates of wealth.
And, worse than all, they give promotion to the clergy who besmear them
with flattery. To take the other view, if the Apostle’s meaning
be that marriage is necessary in a bishop, the Apostle himself ought
not to have been a bishop, for he said, 1 Cor. vii. 7. “Yet I would that all men were
even as I myself.” And John will be thought unworthy of this
rank, and all the virgins, and the continent, the fairest gems that
give grace and ornament to the Church. Bishop, priest, and deacon, are
not honourable distinctions, but names of offices. And we do not read: 1 Tim. iii. 1.“If a man seeketh the office of a
bishop, he desireth a good degree,” but, “he desireth a
good work,” because by being placed in the higher order an
opportunity is afforded him, if he choose to avail himself of it, for
the practice of virtue.